By Felix Ker on November 14, 2007

If Sunshine Empire makes you money without having you to work, everyone just gotta invest and then no one will have to work. This is not a right cycle.

SINGAPORE: The Commercial Affairs Department (CAD) has launched investigations into multi-level marketing (MLM) firm, Sunshine Empire.

The probe by the white collar crime buster comes just over a month after the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) placed the firm on an investor-alert list which zooms in on those who may be conducting activities regulated by the MAS without authority.

Sunshine was also put on a similar list by Malaysian authorities a few months ago.

MLM firms, which are legal in Singapore, typically invite people to pay cash for the right to market goods to other people. They also get cash for recruiting other MLM marketeers.

Read more (CNA)

What do I know?

I got to know Sunshine Empire through a friend few months back and according to him, he earns quite alot through the investment plans. The investment plans earns him much much more than what any local bank’s investment plans can give. I’m going to stop here about what I know – I’ve got no facts since it’s a ‘hear-say’.

Whats wrong?

Just think. You think investing $20k and you’re getting back $40k in a year without having to do any work? Nothing is free, my dad always says.

Even if stock markets are bullish right now, it’s near to impossible for anyone to just invest for you and get back so much. Hey, do you know how many hedge funds went bankrupt last and this year?

Is this publicity or bad news for the company?

Until now, no one knows. 

Positive: This piece of news may invite more investors. “Oh, so Sunshine Empire can earn me lots of money!”

Negative: Oh shit. I want my money back now. I’m going over to their head office to meet …”

My two pennies worth

I am NOT an investor of Sunshine Empire. Neither am I a supporter of the company. And, I’m not having anything against the Empire (Why should I?).

Investors may want to get back what they invested few months back, but I’m quite sure that the company wouldn’t allow that. If everyone does that, they’ll close down soon. So good luck guys.

I NEED MONEY, HELP ME

If you’re thinking about investing with Sunshine Empire, I suggest you visit your nearby banking partner, be it DBS, POSB, Standard Chartered, Maybank, HSBC, UOB or Citibank to arrange for a fixed deposit account. At least banks are more reliable with their lower but realistic interest rate at maybe 4% per annum.

We warned you. =)

Category: Money Matters

Tagged: , , , , ,

Related entries:

  1. Towards the end of Sunshine Empire
  2. 2008 – Whats up?
  3. Marsiling Secondary School: Thought of the Week (17 April 2007)
  4. Few reasons why I blog
  5. Cyberville vs Twinco

1,014 Responses to “Sunshine Empire: Whats next?”

  1. nancy says:

    hi my name’s nancy i’m from mongolia and i just wanna know that how can i return my money back from sunshine empire company i almost invest bout 100k. so please let me know if there anyone who get’s the money back. i hope u guys will help

  2. Been Cheated says:

    Curse him JP and others. Is same like STEVEN YEAM NETWORK..idiot and others upline from LAMPE BERGER

  3. WWZ Victim says:

    Win Win Zone Sdn Bhd in Malayasia officially closed down on September 2010 .

    All forex invester loss their Forex money .

    WWZ’s Director : Bobby Lieu (019-4300399) still in hiding , afraid to meet member .

    George (012-4945019 ) had beaten by member because of giving empty promises .

    Bobby & George very actively involved in Sunshine Empire’s Scam during 2009 .

  4. LH.Lee says:

    Animal James Ong and Bobby Lieu are truely scammer .

    God will sure punish them .

  5. Felix says:

    Mr. James Ong and Bobby Lieu are Malaysian .
    And now both of them afraid to appear in Penang ,Malaysia .

    1) 7 months they never pay world pool money to all Malaysia member .

    2) Forex money all lose . can’t even earn a single cent .

    All WWZ member lose money .

  6. emly Laguna says:

    Pastor gary, dont ruin WWZ with your actions,.. with your text messaging, you are discouraging my downlines. dont ruin the company that gives us food for our tables. you already earn millions and we only earn a little from this so let us have the chance to earn like you did. and can’t you be grateful for the things you received? pastor ka pa namang naturingan,,, act, think, and do like a pastor.

  7. Felix - Laguna says:

    Thanks Rolando for exposing the plot by one man to bring down a great company like Winwinzone Phils. Inc and we all know that guy is Gary Leoncio. I heard from the Council Members why Gary is unhappy based on the these events and without prejudice to anyone, these are all facts and you be the judge;

    1. On Sept 26, 2010 – Gary ALONE took ALL the Profit Share of the Council Slots amounting to millions (this was witnessed by thousands of people at the Grand launching);

    2. In the 1st Council Meeting in early Nov., 2010 – Gary alone took 50% Share of the Profit Share of the Council and gave the remaining 50% to be shared by the remaining 9 Council Members;

    3. At the 2nd Council Meeting, the Council Members requested Sir James to take back the role of country stockistship (as there were many complaints about Mrs Miernie Leoncio’s being very proud and rude to the Distributors & Stockists. Sir James agreed and Gary also agreed during the 2nd Council meeting to hand over but the date of handing over was not fixed. No promise was ever made by Sir James to Gary at any time regarding the exclusivity of Stockistship to be handled by Gary in the Philippines.

    4. Sir James requested Gary to share the next Council’s Profit Sharing to be fair to all the other top leaders of Winwinzone Phils Inc and Sir James reminded also to Gary regarding the Stockistship handing over to the Company.

    5. Because of these 2 incidents ie. sharing of Council’s Profit Share & returning the stockistship to the company, Gary started his attacks on Sir James and Winwinzone Phils Inc. It all started at ASYA Performers’ Treat Dec 18, 2010 when Mrs Miernie Leoncio walked out as Sir James were about to make his speech in front of all the performers. This was followed by numerous private discussions by Gary with top leaders of the company with many text blasts all to discredit Sir James & Winwinzone Phils. On Jan 3, 2011, during the Council meeting, Gary again attacked Sir James with harsh words and rude behavior. Witnessed by all Council members who were shocked at his behavior, even Sir James tried to calm him down. After that meeting, Gary continued with his threats & schemes all designed to bring down Winwinzone & Sir James.

    All these resulted in Gary’s suspension in early January, 2011.

    All the Council members and leaders have decided to continue with Winwinzone despite Gary’s attempts to discredit the company & Sir James because they believe in Sir James and Winwinzone. This frustrates Gary and in his desperate attempt, he resorts to threatening complaints to BIR to destroy Winwinzone.

    Winwinzone has always issued Official receipts to all our distributors ever since they took over as Country Stockist but unfortunately Mr Gary Leoncio/ Mrs Miernie Leoncio via their company 4&1 Global Markets Inc never issued Official Receipts during their role as country stockist for the entire 2010, perhaps someone should report them to the BIR instead! We also wonder if Gary Leoncio reports his income to BIR.

    Sir Gary, you have already earned and profited so much with Winwinzone, unlike others. So many Filipino livelihoods depend on Winwinzone.

    For the sake of many people, please move on with your life. You call yourself a Pastor but your actions depicts more like a man possessed by the devil.

    You have already text blasted your resignation from Winwinzone on January 8, 2011 and on this blog on Jan 10, 2011. If you are unhappy, appoint a good lawyer and sue Winwinzone. There is a proper time and place for everything.

    May God have mercy on you and your family. God Bless Pastor.

    • Elmo says:

      kumita kana ng milliones pano naman ang iba? ang wwz ay maayos na kompanya at magandang produkto. huwag mo naman kaming sirain pastor

  8. Rolando Dixon says:

    As a retired lawyer, one of the basic principles taught in law schools is confidentiality. I am not sure how Atty. Mario Rellora was giving comments about her clients problems in blogs like this, unless perhaps he is not really an Attorney! Furthermore, if you are a litigator, u will not make a warning in public but proceed straight into legal action. Something fishy is going on here….

    Look at the times of the comments of these 4 purportedly different people;

    (1) Atty. Mario Rellora says: January 5, 2011 at 6:44 pm
    (2) WWZ Laguna member says: January 5, 2011 at 7:14 pm and
    (3) Gina – Batangas says: January 5, 2011 at 7:25 pm
    (4) WWZ Malaysia member says: January 5, 2011 at 7:35 pm…..very very fishy ha?

    It is as if one guy is seated in an internet cafe somewhere in Manila, busy creating new email accounts and making these comments under anonymous names.

    I believe it is the same guy who is determined to go the extra mile just to discredit WWZ. Furthermore, the word “scammers” is not commonly used in Malaysia but very common amongst Filipinos…..and the plot thickens….

    Let us check out the times and dates of the other comments;

    (a) BIR – Letigation Team NCR says: January 9, 2011 at 10:18 am
    (b) BIR Legal and Inspection Group NCR says: January 9, 2011 at 10:21 am
    (c) eric rosales – VERA7 says: January 9, 2011 at 10:28 am

    Aha, again, probably the same guy assuming the roles of different people making comments. Also take note that the spelling of “Letigation” is incorrect. Then suddenly from “BIR-Letigation Team NCR” it becomes “BIR Legal and Inspection Group NCR”. Question, can a Govt Dept changes name within 3 minutes? Very suspicious indeed….

    And I guess whoever that person is, he adds a third party eric rosales just to make it all look real.

    Lastly, look at the icon “brown little creature” used for all the above different people…… ha ha, they are the same! Conclusion is it is the same person!

    Wow, what a performance but unfortunately a Bad One! I wonder who that guy really is? I guess if you are telling the truth and you have facts, figures as evidence to substantiate your claim, you would put your real name & contact number. However, if your comments are only to create a nuisance, then you will simply hide like a coward behind an anonymous name or names……

  9. Gary Leoncio says:

    TO EVERYONE CONCERN. Here is the text message I sent to James Ong, the leaders and distributors:

    Good day to all. I would like to inform the public particularly my co leaders and distributors that starting January 8, 2011. I am discontinuing my involvement in the leadership and endorsement of Winwinzone Phil. Inc. For months already I have not been in good business dealings with my friend Mr. James Ong until this day . It happens even to the best of friends just like us. For the sake of friendship and Christian Brotherhood I opted deciding this way. I wish all my co-leaders and distributor and to my dear friend Sir James, all the best. To GOD BE THE GLORY…

    • TOP PERFORMER GENSAN GROUP says:

      “I am discontinuing my involvement in the leadership and endorsement of Winwinzone Phil. Inc.”

      pastor gary, so you’re discontinuing your support to WWZ. with the word discontinue, check this definition out…

      Main Entry: discontinue
      Part of Speech: verb
      Definition: prevent activity from going on
      Synonyms: abandon, bag it, blow off, break off, call it quits, cease, close, desist, disconnect, disjoin, dissever, disunite, drop, end, finish, give over, give up, halt, interpose, interrupt, intervene, kill, knock off, leave off, part, pause, put an end to, quit, refrain from, scrub, separate, stop, surcease, suspend, terminate

      pastor, sa paghinto mo sa WWZ, kami ay magpapatuloy na! GO GENSAN Group!

  10. fenelle Santos says:

    regarding the company policy, you’re the council member. instead of complaining, you should rather give ideas to strengthen the company right? mr or ms COUNCIL member, as a council you should protect us little distributors. and do you have a sense of decency to give your name? i remember when i attended the Grand launching. you with the 001 received millions or not millions thousand from the profit sharing, not only that, from your binary income and stockist income. let me ask you this, are you declaring your personal income to the BIR? if in your heart you want fairness and compliance, you should do it first right? ask yourself am i paying my taxes? if not, don’t even have the courage to complain, because everything you do or say might be used against you. GOD BLESS you! ..

  11. eric rosales - VERA7 says:

    Poor members, believing a lot to this foreign businessmen. They are now Millionaires and i think winwinzone members are getting poorer as they encourage more prospects to engage. Stop this mess. Have pity on them winwinzone. – VERA7

  12. BIR Legal and Inspection Group NCR says:

    BIR will look deep into this.
    “Statutory Offenses and Penalties Title X, NIRC.”

    BIR wants to hear from you. We welcome your queries, comments and suggestions. Feel free to email us at [email protected]

    FOR COMPLAINTS:
    BIR National Office Bldg.,
    Agham Road, Diliman,
    Quezon City, Philippines
    Trunkline:
    929-7676 | 927-2511

  13. BIR - Letigation Team NCR says:

    BIR will look deep into this.
    “Statutory Offenses and Penalties Title X, NIRC.”

    BIR wants to hear from you. We welcome your queries, comments and suggestions. Feel free to email us at [email protected]

    FOR COMPLAINTS:
    BIR National Office Bldg.,
    Agham Road, Diliman,
    Quezon City, Philippines
    Trunkline:
    929-7676 | 927-2511

  14. WWZ Council member says:

    Don’t expect too much on the profit sharing for council and the top performers. But how about other issues like the non-issuance of official receipts to members, stockists? We are now in danger of being investigated by the BIR. Again and again, NO company policy. Is there any changes or solutions, answer to this? Kindly explain to us Mrs. Santos.

    • fenelle Santos says:

      regarding the company policy, you’re the council member. instead of complaining, you should rather give ideas to strengthen the company right? mr or ms COUNCIL member, as a council you should protect us little distributors. and do you have a sense of decency to give your name? i remember when i attended the Grand launching. you with the 001 received millions or not millions thousand from the profit sharing, not only that, from your binary income and stockist income. let me ask you this, are you declaring your personal income to the BIR? if in your heart you want fairness and compliance, you should do it first right? ask yourself am i paying my taxes? if not, don’t even have the courage to complain, because everything you do or say might be used against you. GOD BLESS you!

  15. WWZ Malaysia member says:

    Filipinos beware!!! Hongkong beware!!!
    We are all victimized here in Malaysia by these people: Bobby Lieu, George. James Ong of WWZ philippines is in big problem. DOn’t let this scammers continue victimizing people. We are all against this scammers!!!!!!

  16. Gina - Batangas says:

    I was invited twice in Lipa Batangas where they conduct BOM’s. I invested P20,250 thinking that it would generate interest or monthly profit share as they promised but until now I only got 31 ringgits or Php418.50 since October. Very nice investment huh.. I shouldn’t invested here if only just to earn one time and so little share. Thank you winwinzone for the Php418.50!

    • fenelle santos says:

      Profit sharing is just a bonus… the products you bought will not gain any profit to you if you will not sell it. what we have for the scalar energy products is wellness and business for you to sell. the products is not the investments itself.

    • fenelle santos says:

      Profit sharing is just a bonus… the products you bought will not gain any profit to you if you will not sell it. what we have for the scalar energy products is wellness and business for you to sell. the products is not the investments itself. go work your network and be a performer and council member so that you can see the profit sharing move…

  17. WWZ Laguna member says:

    This company must be investigated by BIR for not issuing OFFICIAL RECEIPTS to members. They earned a lot of Millions yet they evade Tax by not issuing receipts. Filipinos should be aware to this kind of SCAM. Mr. James Ong always tell us his favorite quotes ” WWZ underpromise but Overdelivers” Really? Oh poor guy… Very dishonest man. Enjoy the money of the Filipinos Mr. James Ong and Bobby Lieu. Godbless you two.

  18. Atty. Mario Rellora says:

    Win Win Zone Phils. must prepare their vivid explanation as to how this things gets into worst. Legal actions shall be imposed if still unattended. I have Win Win Zone clients with the same complaints on your World Pool Scheme and Forex.

    • fenelle santos says:

      law actions against profit sharing? Sir let me remind you that profit sharing is just a BONUS from the company. and it’s part of the program. and what’s wrong? they are giving the profit sharing to people who really deserve the profit sharing… regarding the forex, they are not forcing anyone to join the forex. it’s their own decision right? dont join the forex if you’re unsure of it…

  19. Felix says:

    Win Win Zone’ Bobby ?

    That idoit always tell people he got Doctrate ?

    He actually ex-Sunshine Empire .

    Dishonest guy .

    Many Win Win Zone member now looking for him .

  20. WWZ Victim says:

    ian manguera ,

    We think you should not ask people in here about WWZ .

    You go and call Bobby directly .Ask idiot Bobby what happen to Malaysia member .

    Ask him how he treated Malaysia member .

    We sure Bobby will not answer you b’cos he really dida lot of bad thing to all Malaysia’ member.

  21. WWZ Member- Malaysia says:

    Bobby of Win Win Zone now is afraid to conduct any meeting for Malaysia member .

    4 months already ,all WWZ member do not get any ” World Pool ” money.

    Forex : all loss .
    World Pool : Never pay member money .

    You call this good company ?

  22. ianm says:

    where do you pay your investment? to bobby or bank in it to fxprimus? forex is gain or loss you have a chance to gain ad loss us well

    kindly email all your names:
    at [email protected]

    my investment here is doing well i already withdraw some of my money and still doing great… but ia ready what ever happen on my investment because this is forex youll gain youll losse

    thanks,

    ian manguera

  23. Jessie says:

    I and my familty from KL .
    We had invested in Win Win Zone forex .

    All money loss .

    Bobby of Win Win Zone show us the trade history is fake .

    Now Win Win Zone not even pay us ” World Pool ” money .

  24. WWZ Member- Malaysia says:

    If Win Win Zone as good as you said .

    You go and ask WWZ to conduct a meeting for all Malaysia member .

    We want to see if WWZ dare to do it or not .

    You just need to update here when WWZ will have the meeting .

    Now WWZ management afraid to conduct any meeting for Malaysia member .

  25. WWZ Member- Malaysia says:

    Every member of WWZ do not receive World Pool Money .

    WWZ forex worst . 80% investment monet loss .

    The manager Bobby ( H/P: 6019-4300399)
    afraid the appear in Malaysia .

    The forex report they shown is fake .

    You may ask any of WWZ member in Malaysia .

    Don’t Join Win Win Zone .

    Empty Shell Company

    • Ian Manguera says:

      1. If Winwinzone is a scam, why are they still the Super IB for FX Primus? This shows that they are not a scam. FX Primus would be the first party to isolate itself from Winwinzone if it is a scam.

      2. Bobby doesn’t even know James Phang so how can James Phang be linked to Winwinzone?

      3. This is not a scam because your money is with FXPRIMUS and not with Winwinzone and through Winwinzone’s professional Forex traders many investors in the region are gaining from their investment.

      4. Many people are just jealous of the success of Winwinzone and they just want to spread negative rumours but despite all these, Winwinzone is growing bigger & stonger.

      5. People need to understand Winwinzone’s Marketing Plan & Policy to appreciate the truth. Why not just contact us rather than putting up lies on blogs. We are a legal entity & we have an office, just look for us or call us.

      6. Winwinzone is now considering bringing legal action against lies being targetted towards the company.

  26. ianm says:

    winwinzone is legitimate…

    your money is in
    fxprimus

    Offshore International Brokerage and Investment Firm

    No Dealing Desk – STP (Straight-Thru Processing)
    Best Liquidity From Multiple Tier One Banks
    Trade Forex, Metals, CFD’s & Forex Options
    Independently Administered Segregated Client Accounts by Turnstone Corporate (Mauritius) Limited
    Leading MT4 Platform for Desktop, Laptop, PDA,
    Smart Phone
    6. Syariah Compliant Accounts Available
    7. Audits Conducted by World Class Firm.
    8. Fully Licensed and Regulated by FSC

    Nothing to fear only portion of your money that you will put and investment a small amount of $500 and let your money work for you, 5% a month/ compounding interest

    email me: [email protected]

    Where doing great in the philippines and we are proud to say that this is LEGITIMATE BUSINESS AND INVESTMENT… JOIN US SEE YOUR SELF THE CHANGES IN YOUR FINANCIAL ASPECT IN THE NEAR FUTURE……..
    PAYAMAN DITO….. YOU’LL BE RICH

  27. Working Class says:

    Hello,

    Are we sure that SeaNet International is one of these scam networks? We as my family put all of our money to SeaNet International. I mean really all of our money. $34.000! it will take my 6 years of hard working to collect that money again. Right now i can’t withdraw any money from bank accounts. I’m in a mood that i can easily commit suicide right now.

    Are we sure that SeaNet International is one of those scam companies? Is the money lost? Please someone who knows answer me. I’m deadly stressed. If it is true, we all lost the money as a family and i lost all the trust of my family.

  28. winwin_forex says:

    is this true? i am planning to invest in forex for $500. but having a chance to read this thread, winwinzone is a scam and its offices are shut down? how come they were able to have alliance in fxprimus?

    good thing i’ve read this one. thanks!

  29. WWZ Member says:

    Win Win Zone Sdn Bhd in Malayasia officially closed down on September 2010 .

    All forex invester loss their Forex money .

    WWZ’s Director : Bobby (019-4300399) still in hiding , afraid to meet member .

    George (012-4945019 ) had beaten by member because of giving empty promises .

    Bobby & George very actively involved in Sunshine Empire’s Scam during 2009 .

  30. hengzzz says:

    7 face charges in Thailand’s Sunshine Empire case
    Tue, Aug 31, 2010

    THAILAND’S Department of Special Investigation (DSI) has submitted and presented to public prosecutors seven suspects in the case of Sunshine Empire (Thailand) Co Ltd’s pyramid scheme, which sold health products and 4G cell phones.

    Source:
    http://www.asiaone.com/News/Latest+News/Asia/Story/A1Story20100831-234894.html

  31. Felix Ker says:

    So, any news you all have to share for now?

  32. Steven Lee says:

    Win Win Zone Sdn Bhd have not approval from Bank Negara .

    Win Win Zone Sdn Bhd is illegal in Malaysia .

    All member loss their investment .

  33. WWZ Member says:

    Another new Scam in Malaysia & Indonesia .

    Company: Win Win Zone Sdn Bhd ( Forex)

    Location : Malaysia,Philipine & Singapore

    Consultant in Asia: Bobby ( H/P: 6019-4300399)
    Represanter in Malaysia: George (H/P: 6012-4945019)
    Represanter in Philipine: James
    Represanter in Singapore: Falcon (H/P: 6012-4740669)
    Forex Performance on : May ,2010 : Loss 50%
    Forex Performance on : June ,2010 : Loss 70%
    Office : None
    MLM Lisence : None
    Bank Negara Lisence : None
    Marketing Director : James Phang

    Member still can not able to withdraw money .

    • ian manguera says:

      To all Concern:

      1. If Winwinzone is a scam, why are they still the Super IB for FX Primus? This shows that they are not a scam. FX Primus would be the first party to isolate itself from Winwinzone if it is a scam.

      2. Bobby doesn’t even know James Phang so how can James Phang be linked to Winwinzone?

      3. This is not a scam because your money is with FXPRIMUS and not with Winwinzone and through Winwinzone’s professional Forex traders many investors in the region are gaining from their investment.

      4. Many people are just jealous of the success of Winwinzone and they just want to spread negative rumours but despite all these, Winwinzone is growing bigger & stronger.

      5. People need to understand Winwinzone’s Marketing Plan & Policy to appreciate the truth. Why not just contact us rather than putting up lies on blogs. We are a legal entity & we have an office, just look for us or call us. http://www.winwinzone.com

      6. Winwinzone is now considering bringing legal action against lies being targetted towards the company.

  34. WWZ Member says:

    Another new Scam in Malaysia & Indonesia .

    Scam Compnay : Win Win Zone

    Nature of Business : Forex

    Scammer Name : Bobby

    Contact Number: +6019-4300399

    Problem : 1) No Money Pay out for World Pool Account
    2) Causing investor heavy loss in Forex.

  35. Newton says:

    Then was should we do…….

    a. Jackie Hoo Choon Cheat was convicted on the charge of fraudulent trading under the Companies Act and all the charges involving criminal breach of trust as an agent of Sunshine Empire under the Penal Code. He was sentenced to 7 years imprisonment.

    b. James Phang Wah was convicted on the charge of fraudulent trading under fraudulent trading under the Companies Act and all the charges involving criminal breach of trust as an agent and falsification of Sunshine Empire’s accounts under the Penal Code. He was sentenced to 9 years imprisonment and fined $60,000.

    c. Neo Kuon Huay was convicted on all charges involving the falsification of Sunshine Empire’s accounts under the Penal Code. She was sentenced to a fine amounting to S$60,000.

    d. Yong Wai Hong had pleaded guilty to all charges of false declaration of the share capital of various companies under the Companies Act. He was convicted and has been sentenced to a fine amounting to S$24,000.

  36. hengzzz says:

    Jackie HOO & some sunshine empire achievers are in
    mapleX alliance (MAL)
    Degree 10 ( D10 )

    Source : http://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/showthread.php?t=2806761

    Degree 10 – Official Facebook Page

    Source : http://www.facebook.com/pages/Degree-10-Official-Facebook-Page/124563207575339?v=wall

  37. WWZ Member says:

    Don’t join Win Win Zone .

    All member loss their forex money & can not do withdrawer .

    Same as James Phang’s style .

    Bobby (James Phang’s follower) is a scammer .

  38. sunshine empire cheated says:

    James Phang and all his kakitangan are cheated, no brain, no heart, they would pay at hell, no good sleep, no good death, now still enjoy but when the time come true, he and his kakitangan must pay more than had they stole from us. Be patient, pau ing i ting lai….

  39. SE Victim says:

    James Phang’s New Scam

    Company: Win Win Zone Sdn Bhd ( Forex)
    Location : Malaysia,Philipine & Singapore
    Consultant in Asia: Bobby ( H/P: 6019-4300399)
    Represanter in Malaysia: George (H/P: 6012-4945019)
    Represanter in Philipine: James
    Represanter in Singapore: Falcon (H/P: 6012-4740669)
    Forex Performance on : May ,2010 : Loss 5%
    Forex Performance on : June ,2010 : Loss 10%
    Office : None
    MLM Lisence : None
    Bank Negara Lisence : None
    Marketing Director : James Phang

    Member still do not able to withdraw money .

  40. sayed says:

    RNRB is 15 month organisation doing forex, gold trading along with event Mangament .Just started this Brand new Investment plan, all files attached

    Very good investment plan which give weekly 10% on your investment…

    Company Name is RNRB Traders.

    http://www.rnrb.biz

    Min. investment Rs.4500/- + 500(service fee)

    Weekly 10%(Rs.450/-) is directly transferred in bank account.

    Direct Referal :15%

    Binary:12.5%

    Level Income and Rewards

    Please find the attached document for ur reference of RNRB Traders, who has paid tax of 96 lakhs for event management this march 2010.

    RNRB TRADERS IS IN TOP 5 SERVICES TAX(FOR EVENT MANAGEMENT) PAYEES LIST OF GOVT. OF INDIA, THIS IS JUST THE BEGINNING……

    TAKE UR TOP POSITIONS NOW……….

    Winning Regards,

    SAYED

  41. Ken Lee says:

    Let us all arrange a time and visit James Phang .

    For Sure James Phang not going to re-fund our money .

    We must act together and ask our hard earn money back .

    James Phang’s Office:

    The Adelphi,
    1 Coleman Street ,
    #06-07 Singapore ,
    178903.

    Gathering : 12/6/2010
    Time : 10am
    Purpose : Ask our money back from scammer James Phang .

  42. GOD says:

    We still need to discussing Sunshine Empire , Cause we suffer a lots , James Phang must go to Jail .

  43. Goh says:

    James Phang still have :
    1) GRI (Grand Royale International)
    2) Seanet International Group,Dubai
    3) Emcom ,Taiwan
    4) Grand Elitia
    5) ESA Trader

    James Phang will be getting richer and richer .

    James Phang & his stupid family enjoying their life in Hong Kong .

    Leaving all his old SE member to suffer .

    James Phang is truly an animal.

  44. taiko says:

    didn’t realise ppl still discussing this thing. i have totally forgot about until i saw the 150$ company magazine at my shoes tray that terry gave which he claimed he paid for it and brought it all the way to sarawak.

    when come to think of it, he did really work hard for his 1st offline promoting project after all his online investment falled. he was then came here with david tan, terry tan’s guidance, i wonder how he is? i guess from sound of it, terry has surpassed him. during then, only david do the talking, terry is just there to listen.

    not to be rude or anything, above is what i am thinking when this thing float into my mind. perhaps i might think differently if i loose money, but i think i didn;t. 1 a/c profit and another 1 lost which breakeven afterall. all i really lose is the time wasted and faint of something so convincing could falled.

  45. Goh says:

    James Phang still have GRI (Grand Royale International,Seanet International Group & Emcom businss ) .
    James Phang will be getting richer and richer .
    James Phang & his stupid family enjoying their life in Hong Kong .
    Leaving all his old SE member to suffer .
    James Phang is truly an animal.

  46. Goh says:

    James Phang still have GRI (Grand Royale International,Seanet International Group & Emcom business ) .
    Currently ,James Phang having a very very good income & enjoying his life with his familty in Hong Kong .
    Leaving all his old SE member suffering .
    James Phang do not care about member at all .
    James Phang is an animal.

  47. Goh says:

    James Phang still have GRI (Grand Royale International & Seanet International Group & Emcom) .
    James Phang will be getting richer and richer .

  48. Victim says:

    Very weird .
    All thoese news never mention anything about Emcom & Melaka Project at all. Not a single word .
    Did CAD really investigate Emcom ?

  49. GOD says:

    Now you believe what James Phang said NOW LAW CAN TOUCH THEM ?? Terry Tan : You are NEXT.

    控方指出,阳光大帝从售卖配套取得超过1亿8000万元,虽然约1亿1800万元分发给参与者,不过,大部分的钱落入彭华及他的追随者。控方也指阳光大帝须年年赚取349%盈利,才能维持业务,但那毫不合理,最终将损害后来加入者的利益。

        侯启祥 报道      

     多层传销公司阳光大帝创办人彭华被指以损害公司和参与者的利益致富,从中牟取数百万元利益。       此外,他和妻子梁君花及公司董事何俊杰被指共谋以不法和不诚实的手段致富。    

       彭华被控失信及以欺骗手法营业案昨天开审,控方指出,阳光大帝从售卖配套取得超过1亿8000万元,虽然约1亿1800万元分发给参与者,以鼓励他们购买更多配套,并吸引其他人考虑加入,不过,大部分的钱落入彭华及他的追随者,尤其是彭华本人牟取了至少500万美元(约710万新元)顾问费和津贴。

          而且,控方指阳光大帝必须年年赚取349%盈利,才能维持业务,但那毫不合理,最终将损害后来加入者的利益。      

     现年49岁的彭华、梁君花(46岁)及何俊杰(29岁)今年2月3日被控,彭华面对最多控状,共20项,其次是何俊杰10项,梁君花七项。

          彭华面对的其中14项控状,指他触犯刑事法典,包括8项教唆何俊杰失信94万7000多元,6项与梁君花共谋作假账。他也面对一项以欺骗手法营业,触犯公司法令控状。其余5项则是触犯公司法令及影片法令的控状。     

      何俊杰除了被控协助彭华失信外,还面对多两项控状,包括以欺骗手法营业以及未确保公司账目清楚,抵触公司法令控状。梁君花除了被控与彭华共谋作假账外,则面对多一项向商业注册局呈报假资料,触犯公司法令控状。    

    彭华昨早9时左右来到初庭,神情轻松。控方以彭华、何俊杰及梁君花面对的抵触刑事法典和那项以欺骗手法营业控状都有关联,向法官提出联合审讯申请,获得批准。

          主控官艾迪阿都拉副检察司在开庭陈词时指彭华和何俊杰以欺诈方式售卖高回报配套。       主控官说,阳光大帝并没有经营实质有盈利的生意,也没实质资金支付参与者高回报,他们清楚如果没有新资金投入,公司无法持续支付高回报。      

     控方将证明如果没有新资金投入,参与者迟早一分钱都拿不回。  

    彭华得公司百万元免息贷款助解决个人债务

          此外,阳光大帝提供彭华100万元免息贷款,协助他以前的公司解决银行和税务债务。这些公司目前已停止营业。控方将证明阳光大帝提供至少4000万元无抵押免息贷款给生意伙伴。   

        针对刑事法典的控状,主控官指彭华、梁君花及何俊杰共谋以不法和不诚实的手段致富。       主控官说,控方将证明彭华要何俊杰委任梁君花为集团营业董事,让梁君花自动获得相等于公司1%净营业额的款项,犯下失信罪。公司8次支付梁君花约94万7000多元的“销售奖励”,为了掩盖事实,梁君花和彭华6次共谋作假账。   

        控方将传召21名证人,包括来自英国伦敦的专家证人卢克·斯特德曼、14名参与者以及阳光大帝的会计员供证。卢克·斯特德曼是特许会计师,也是法证专家。

         主控官指出,控方的专家证人将证明阳光大帝的计划在任何合理情况下,都不可能持续。       他说,根据专家证人的意见,公司付给参与者的回报,并不是来自实在的生意盈利,而是新加入者投入的资金。专家证人的分析显示,阳光大帝每年须赚取349%盈利,才能维持业务。公司支付参与者的回报不实际,无法持续,最终将损害后来加入者的利益。    

       控方传召的14名参与者来自不同背景,他们将证明受高回报吸引加入计划,而阳光大帝夸大其词,声称公司及相关公司拥有或管理的海外计划都很成功,使他们相信公司有能力支付高回报。

    2010-03-11 23:34

  50. James Phang Status says:

    The trial has finally come to end.

    新加坡讯)长达1个半月的阳光大帝案今早结束审讯,案件总共传召29位证人,法官将在7月16日作出裁决。   新明日报报道,本地多层传销公司阳光大帝(Sunshine Empire)创办人彭华(49岁)被指以欺骗方式经营业务,以及教唆失信超过94万7000元公款等,被控上法庭。   彭华的妻子梁君花(46岁)以及阳光大帝董事何俊杰(29岁)也被指与彭华共谋触犯公司法令或刑事法典,一起被控。   三人各获准以60万元保释在外,法官将在3个月后,即7月16日于第7庭做出裁决,判定三人是否有罪。 《联合早报网》(编辑:黄爱莲)

    Source : http://tw.myblog.yahoo.com/emtyap

  51. hengzzz says:

    The trial had finished on 16 Apr 10.

    (新加坡讯)长达1个半月的阳光大帝案今早结束审讯,案件总共传召29位证人,法官将在7月16日作出裁决。   新明日报报道,本地多层传销公司阳光大帝(Sunshine Empire)创办人彭华(49岁)被指以欺骗方式经营业务,以及教唆失信超过94万7000元公款等,被控上法庭。   彭华的妻子梁君花(46岁)以及阳光大帝董事何俊杰(29岁)也被指与彭华共谋触犯公司法令或刑事法典,一起被控。   三人各获准以60万元保释在外,法官将在3个月后,即7月16日于第7庭做出裁决,判定三人是否有罪。 《联合早报网》(编辑:黄爱莲)

  52. Phang says:

    Ok …lets terry tan enjoyed James Phang , We enjoy James Phang daughter , f-u-c-k-e-r James Phang cheated us . He should suffer this pain.

  53. leong says:

    i think terry tan quiet enjoyed this services by james phang , that why love him so much.

  54. Tan says:

    We also love James Phang more than terry tan….all malaysian ,Thiland ,taiwan , SE member love to f-u-c-k him. One people one stroke …hahaha.

    Terry Tan going to F-u-c-k James Phang a-s-s hole,
    James Phang also want to F-u-c-k terry tan a-s-s hole.

  55. Terry Tan says:

    My godfather will be fine as no law can touch him.

    It is CAD that is dragging its feet. They are still trying hard to have a solid case against my godfather.

    Long Live James Phang!

    We love you!

    Warmest Regards,
    Terry Tan
    Your Favourite Son from Malaysia

  56. JP Info says:

    Dragging .
    James Phang is trying to drag the case .
    James Phang still have good income from GRI(Grand Royale International) .
    Still enjoying his life in Hong Kong .

  57. lim says:

    Hi all :
    Please update James Phang status ?
    Singapore court already have any results?

  58. Singapore ESA says:

    I have warned you all before , GRI & ESA is James Phang’s scam .
    Now ,money can not withdraw & loss all your investment money .
    You all believe me now ?

  59. Jack says:

    I have warned you all before , GRI & ESA is truelly James Phang’s scam .
    Now ,money can not withdraw & loss all your investment money .
    You all believe me now ?

  60. T.H.Lee says:

    Chicken Terry Tan ,
    Afraid telling truth about ESA lossing member’s hard earn money .

  61. T.H.Lee says:

    Chicken Terry Tan ,
    Afraid to tell truth about ESA lossing money .
    Once A Chicken , Always A Chicken .
    Better ask monkey Andy to join you ,a chicken for the holiday .
    Chicken Terry Tan & Monkey Andy go holiday together.

  62. Terry Tan says:

    Dear Biggest Losers,

    If you think I scammed you, then feel free to make a police report against me. I want to see what “action” the police will take.

    Most probably they will laugh at your greed and say you are stupid not to make money when everyone is making tonnes of money in SE, GE, ESA and etc. For all you know the police is in ESA making money. LOL!

    Please show proof that ESA is losing money for you. Most of you are here badmouthing without any solid proof.

    By the way, I am going for another week of holiday and will pray for all you sad souls out there losing big money.LOL!

    Warmest Regards,
    Terry Tan
    012-4882248

    p/s: Dr.Andy from ESA is joining me for the holiday too. So lovely isn’t it?

  63. Candy says:

    40% of ESA member having trouble when withdraw they investment money .

  64. ESA - Loh says:

    24th March,2010
    ESA Singapore faced charges from Singapore Gov because of illegally collecting money for Forex trade.

  65. Michael Toh says:

    COURT NO 7: BEFORE DISTRICT JUDGE, MS JASVENDER KAUR

    Monday, 29th March 2010) DAC 7740-46/09 & 2 others
    PP v (B1) NEO KUON HUAY
    (B2) HOO CHOON CHEAT JACKIE
    (B3) PHANG WAH
    Sec 477A PC Cap 224
    … 5th day

    Tuesday, 30th March 2010) Ditto – [DAC 7740-46/09 & 2 others]

    Wednesday,31st March 2010) Ditto – [DAC 7740-46/09 & 2 others]

    Thursday, 01st April 2010) Ditto – [DAC 7740-46/09 & 2 others]

    Friday, 02nd April 2010) GOOD FRIDAY

    source
    http://www.subcourts.gov.sg/hearing_list_courts.doc

  66. Michael Toh says:

    March 2010 , ESA caused me loss RM56,000 of my forex money .
    Can not find Monkey Andy Low. He bull shit us about his EA .
    He is a scammer .

  67. Anti-JP says:

    James Phang still have income from GRI(Grand Royale International).
    He income would not be bank in to his own name .
    CAD ,please investigate bastard James Phang .
    James Phang do not deserve to have a good life .

  68. Anti-JP says:

    Please early go to Singapore court on 29/march /2010 .Bring eggs . Throw to stupid bastard James Phang,Jackie Hoo & JP’s dirty wife .

  69. God says:

    TO all SE/Emmax members . Please early go to Singapore court on 29/march /2010 . James Phang always said NO law can touch them …… The Judgement Day for James Phang and Jackie . Hope they in Jail Forever . They should suffer our painful this time.

  70. Jane says:

    Stupid Monkey Andy Low caused me loss USD18,0000.
    All bull shit .
    Using cheap EA to scam people.
    Monkey Andy Low don’t care about ESA member at all .He only care for his money .

  71. Gan says:

    Now all ESA member know Monkey Andy Low is a liar . Talk cock No.1 .
    Good at hiding as well .

  72. Jack-ESA says:

    Stupid Monkey Andy Low ,
    Please come out and face all ESA member .
    Don’t hide .

  73. Jack-ESA says:

    Where are chicken Terry Tan & stupid Monkey Andy Low hiding now ?

  74. Connie Ooi says:

    A lot ESA member withdraw their money due to heavy losses caused by ESA .
    Now EAS start giving 8% discount in order to win back their customer .
    Too late .Everyone know ESA’s EA is lousy .cheap EA .
    Chicken Terry Tan & Andy Low still hiding .Afraid to meet member .

  75. God says:

    TO all singapore SE/Emmax members . Please early go to the court on 29/march /2010 . James Phang always said NO law can touch them …… The Judgement Day for James Phang and Jackie . Hope they in Jail Forever . They should suffer our painful this time.

  76. Connie Ooi says:

    Idoit Andy Low & Terry Tan ,
    Where are you hiding now ?
    You loss our Forex money .
    Please don’t hide for us like a rat .
    Come out and give us an explanination .

  77. Steven says:

    Andy L.Y.Low & Chicken Terry Tan (ESA) always talk big and give empty promised .
    When Andy Low loss our money ,he intent to hide away and refuse to meet ESA member .
    Their EA is very lousy .Cheap EA.
    Stupid Andy Low .

  78. ESA Member says:

    Last few months, ESA had caused all invester loss their money because of ESA’s lousy EA .Most the their member have left ESA .
    And now ESA trying to give offer to gain back thier customer .
    ESA now having very bad situation .
    All these truth would not be told by Chicken Terry Tan .He only tell one side of the story .
    Terry Tan is truely a Chicken .

  79. Anti-SE says:

    (Grand Royale International)James Phang & Terry Tan’s Update:

    http://blog.omy.sg/shinmin/archives/1760

  80. James Phang says:

    Terry Tan : Dont talking nonsense . We are very difficulty to scammed/conned members money . If you want to continous scam or con members money . Dont bull shit . Just ask them to joint GRI .

  81. James Phang says:

    Terry tan problem is bank account got too much money until 3 generations also cannot finish ,becuase we cheated members money, terry tan problem is have a luxury car to drive because cheated se/emmax members money, terry tan problem is can do anything with my time, Terry tan problem is having to much downlines willing to fight together with me and achieve our goals, after achieved the goals , we closed the networking and scam members money, terry tan problem is having to much time to do anything I want , like cheating and watch x-dvd, he is actor and i am a script. terry tan is to worry about scam to less money from members.

    Thanks

  82. Anti-SE says:

    James Phang & Terry Tan’s Update:

    http://blog.omy.sg/shinmin/archives/1760

  83. Link says:

    James Phang,Terry Tan.where is all the bonuses you promise? You have cheated us, you have cheated the poor and you enjoy the pain incurr on many of us. We have been cheated of hope but trust from our friends and relatives. You take away the trust from us. You are so cruel, evil and cunning. We suffer from your doing, not only financially but the trust others put on us. You have created evil and may this evil fall on you too and with tremendous force. May god punish this evil man!

  84. John Loh says:

    Please , never believe ESA Trader say .
    All bull shit & empty promises.

  85. Teresa says:

    Chicken Terry Tan talk big only .
    ESA really loss a lot of invester money for the past few month .
    Chicken Terry Tan afraid to tell .

  86. HK says:

    I really wish i could see hoe Chicken Terry Tan lay egg in his new car .
    Chicken always do chicken things .Nothnig else.

  87. blog says:

    this is the blog for members that suffer painted after jointed Sunshine Empire / Emmax. Dont forget this , We need our money back from chicken James Phang , and his family.

  88. blog says:

    this is the blog for members that suffer painted after jointed Sunshine Empire / Emmax. Dont forget this , We need our money back from chicken James Phang , and his family.

  89. link says:

    James Phang,
    You are trying to hurt people feeling in here .
    You know that SE victims is already suffer with pain and now what are you trying to do ?
    n’t you really feel thier pain ?
    What else you want from them ?
    Even me ,a lady , would see a guy like you as “nothing” .
    You got no human feeling and you just care about your own ego .
    You mother would not feel pround if she knowing you do these bad thnig to people .
    Shame on you

  90. Ken says:

    Every moring ,Chicken Terry Tan lay 2 eggs in his Porsche and then give the 2 eggs to his mother for breakfast .
    Smart chicken .

  91. ESA Member says:

    Terry Tan afraid to tell people that ESA have loss a lot of money the past 4 month .
    Have you see a chicken driving a Porsche before ?
    Terry Tan is the one .

  92. H.L.Oh says:

    Haha
    Stupid Joker Terry Tan.

  93. H.L.Oh says:

    Haha
    Stupid Joker Terry Tan .

  94. Terry Tan says:

    Yeah my problem is my bank account got too much money until 3 generations also cannot finish, my problem is I have a luxury car to drive, my problem is I can do anything with my time, My problem is having to much downlines willing to fight together with me and achieve our goals, my problem is allowing tom dick and harry to join SE, GE & ESA. My problem is having to much time to do anything I want. My problem is having too many places still need to visit. My problem is just my problem no need to worry about me.

    Thanks

  95. H.L.Oh says:

    Who is this Joker ,Terry Tan ?
    Seems that he is really have no money and try to sales himself in here .
    I really think he got problem .

  96. Terry Tan says:

    Maybe if I let you drive my new car you would understand why people like love to be rich and others like you are still driving Nissan Sunny 120Y. I make it! You are just jealous and blame everyone except yourself. The opportunity was there for you to grab and make money but you all choose to sit and wait for money to drop from the sky while I do hard work marketing, traveling to HK, China, Macau, Singapore, Indonesia and even East Malaysia. What did you do? Sit at home and play computer games? So blame yourself for being a lazy person. From 5 Series I made it to Porsche and you all say I scam people and etc. Proof it if you can, don’t just accuse. You have no life but hide behind the computer to tarnish my reputation. You reap what you sow, that’s the reality.

    By the way, what can you do to me and my money? I am living my dream life now. Money enough for few generations. My future is secured. Thanks to my great planing. So those who wish to follow my great plans, please do call me for a meeting, I am back in KL already.

    Thanks
    Warmest Regards,
    Terry Tan
    012-4882248

  97. Cindy Ooi says:

    Terry Tan ,
    You are trying to hurt people feeling in here .
    You know that SE victims is already suffer with pain and now what are you trying to do ?
    n’t you really feel thier pain ?
    What else you want from them ?
    Even me ,a lady , would see a guy like you as “nothing” .
    You got no human feeling and you just care about your own ego .
    You mother would not feel pround if she knowing you do these bad thnig to people .
    Shame on you .

  98. Boring says:

    Terry Tan ,
    Can you tell other story bo ?
    Just keep on telling about your own car .
    No creative ,boring la……..

  99. ESA Member says:

    See .
    As i told you all . Terry Tan(Joker) now talk very very big .
    He just want to show off his nice car.He got no other words ,only keep showing off his car .
    Pity him.
    Maybe we should give him a chance to satisfy his self ego .
    No harm .

  100. Terry Tan says:

    If you have any proof, show it. I can show you all my business & investments are profitable, just look at my new car that is worth RM860,000. Can you afford it? This is proof enough that I am a rich businessman and enjoying a high life. Birds of the same feather flock together, so rich will always be with rich people while loser like you guys just complain about your ill fate.

    Don’t hope for any refund from me. Cry all you want. You guys are blood suckers hoping me giving you all my hard earned money. I do marketing for SE, GE & ESA and I deserve my all my money. You guys didn’t know how to make use of the opportunity to make fast money.

    Better luck next time, guys!

  101. ESA Member says:

    Terry Tan even afraid to tell the truth about ESA that lose money for the pass 3 months .
    Don’t believe in Terry Tan.
    Noone in ESA like him . He gave a lot ot empty promises .

  102. Joe says:

    Since you are legal why not you adverstist in newspaper ?
    Becasue only legal company can advertist in newspaper.
    This already proof ESA is illegal.
    Scare ? Or no money ?

  103. Terry Tan says:

    I am here presenting profitable business opportunity to everyone here, it shall not be branded it a “scam” without proving its a scam I am promoting. Do you have any proof?

    If you are so sure its a scam, do quickly make a police report on my alleged “scam” business opportunities that I am promoting here.

    Let me warn you the police will laugh at you (maybe even slap you for wasting time) if you all do try. I challenge you to make an official police report against me and the company, let’s see what is the outcome. No law can stop us and we are not illegal. Earning tonnes of money is not illegal in Malaysia.

    Stop being a coward and making me a scapegoat for your investment losses and asking me for a refund here & there. Your wife got period also my fault is it? The Biggest Joker is yourself. This is why I am driving a new Porsche and you driving a loser car.

    Those who are interested to learn the secrets to my success by owning a Porsche before 30 years old, do contact me AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. “Opportunities Wait For No Men/Woman” Don’t be like the rest of sore losers bickering about refund and expect money fall from the sky. I want real leaders will high commitment to success, if you are please contact me.

    Thanks
    Warmest Regards,
    Terry Tan
    012-4882248

  104. Joe says:

    Terry Tan , you are truely joker .
    You better go scam your own mother . Not us.

  105. Terry Tan says:

    I am smart enough to make money in all investment that I choose, What about you all? Come here and make noise. I don’t understand why you all keep losing money and keep asking me for refund. I never take your money. You paid directly to the company (SE,GE or ESA) and the company don’t pay you, is it my fault? But I still get paid from the company, so I have no personal problem with the company. If you have problem go settle with the company yourself.

    I am getting richer day by day and can afford to go Cameroon Highlands for a short break with my new Porsche, while people like you need to work 9-5. Ever wonder why you are so sad? FYI, Cameroon is very cooling and peaceful. Away from crazy people like you guys here. I am looking for long term business partner and those wish to have my lifestyle, do contact me for profitable business opportunities.

    Thanks
    Warmest Regards,
    Terry Tan
    012 – 4882248

  106. ESA Member says:

    That’s Terry Tan . Always talk big when things happen,his leg shake like hell .
    We all think Terry Tan is female.

  107. Joe says:

    To Joker Terry Tan ,
    Just tell us when u brave to meet our Sunshine Empire Member.
    If you so scare to meet us , then don’t make noise in here .
    You go and tell your stupid story to your own mother la….
    Joker.

  108. Joe says:

    Terry Tan , another Joker of ESA .
    ESA only produce Joker & Scammer .
    Hahahaha

  109. ESA Member says:

    Actually ESA is not really doing well for the pass 3 months . Loss money .
    When loss money ,ESA blaim the marketing not well but they never blaim their own EA .Funny excuses.
    A lot of ESA member don’t like Terry Tan. He really talk big .

  110. Vivid says:

    Terry Tan should get a Porsche, a faster car for himself so that it is faster to escape in case he meet up with Sunshine Empire member.
    To escape from people that he had scammed.Good for him.

  111. Singapore Member says:

    Terry Tan ,
    Don’t use your money to press people .We respect a person because of his honesty & sincere.
    If keep showing off of how rich are you ,you are totally a failure .
    You are rich now but you afraid to meet with SE member .Hiding away like a dirty rat.
    Terry Tan just like James Phang’s style .Always use money to throw at people & talk big. When things happen ,hide in rat holes.
    We all pity you(Terry Tan) .

  112. Lee says:

    Terry Tan ,
    Since you make so much money ,why you try to advertist in here ?
    Why not you pay money to advertist in newspoer ?
    It prove the your money is illegal and can’t legally advertist in newspaer .
    This is anti-James Phang blog . Which mean ESA really got relationship with James Phang.
    Have you return all the money which you have scammed to all Sunshine Empire member & Grand Elitia member ?

  113. Terry Tan says:

    I did not force you to join SE, GE or ESA. You all do it on your own free will. Do not blame me or the company if your investment has gone bad. No sure why your investment gone bad while mine is always so good & profitable? Sorry to say, maybe my luck is better than yours. From BMW 5 Series, I made it to Porsche. What about you? You see this is all my hard work finally paying off since SE. If you are jealous, please don’t be. If you want to earn more money, do call me for new investment opportunities. Do it now before its too late.

    Thanks
    Warmest Regards,
    Terry Tan
    012 – 4882284

  114. George says:

    Damn Terry Tan (ESA)
    Scam people’s money to buy Porsche ?
    Should take this idiot to hang .

  115. H.K.Loo says:

    To ESA (Terry Tan),

    When you willing to re-fund our SE money ?
    Don’t you think you can run away with this . We going to track you down .

  116. SE Victim says:

    Terry Tan ,
    Why when we try to call you to yr h/p to ask about our re-fund money which you had scammed us since Seunshine Empire & Grand Elitia ,you don’t not dare to ask our call ?
    Please arrange a location for a meet up to discuss about our re-fund money .
    You must return our money .
    Remember , the money you gained now is ours money .

  117. Terry Tan says:

    Those who doubt ESA’s earning ability, please be informed that I have purchased a Porsche Cayenne GTS with number plate PJN 1118 worth RM860,000.

    Call me for a preview of ESA and all other money making programs that I am currently doing effortlessly that is making good returns every month. I can share with you my secrets to early retirement and success.

    Looking forward to hearing from you all.

    Thanks

    Warmest Regards,
    Terry Tan
    012 – 4882284

  118. Link says:

    This is the last picture for him to memoried …he will be in jail soon . He said he is not in wrong last time but he was wrong to cheated people money , and all member suffered problem , some already suiside due to finiacial problem after joited sunshine empire/emmax….Now …His new company , GRI is like a shit.

  119. Link says:

    Yes ..Dont said too much …finally
    1)James Phang have to return back all the money where by he cheeated from sunshine empire and emmax.
    2)James Phang have to in Jailed forever to prevent he is still con money . We hope this year he will in charge.

  120. Jansher Khan says:

    I read this blog for amusement.

    To all you chest-beating SE members, I can’t believe I found all of you SO…. dis-organised, disunited & empty vessel. Make a lot of noise HERE but hardly got any substance. If I am JP, you hardly worth my attention because you are just a bunch of toothless tigers. So tame. More like a hungry kittens.

    Recently, you got a golden opportunity in the Lunar New Year to make a scene at his house & demand his attention.But you just blow it. The way things are evolving,you can kiss your monies GOODBYE……….

  121. Jonny Liew says:

    James Phang CNY house party had spend SGD48,000. All those money he spend is the money he scamed from SE mmeber .
    James Phang is having a very good life whereby all SE member suffering .

  122. Link says:

    Give James phang some screw and hammer for coming CNY ..cause he cheated us a lots , He should pay for it.

  123. Jonny Liew says:

    James Phang will be having a great CNY party at his house .
    What about all those SE victim who is still suffering caused by James Phang ?
    What are we going to do ?

  124. Link says:

    Are we still continuous to curse James phang, Jackie during chinese new year ?

  125. GRI Management says:

    Dear Our Valued Distributors,

    We will have a very good potential to increase the sales in China this year. Let us forget about Sunshine Empire and have a new start with Facebook,google,yahoo,baidu,skype,hotmail,alibaba.,youtube,gameboy , palystation,xbox.

    I would like to clarify that we have nothing to do with Sunshine Empire .All Sunshine Empire may look for my fuc-king wife about the re-fund of your investment money .

    Currently ,we offer to all Sunshine Empire member for FREE to convert their membership to GRI MEMBER.

    “We Will Be Stronger Ever That No Law Can Touch Us ”

    Regards,

    James Phang

  126. Dear Our Valued Distributors,

    We will have a very good potnetial to increase the sales in China this year. Let us forget about Sunshine Empire and have a new start with Facebook,google,yahoo,baidu,skype,hotmail,alibaba.,youtube,gameboy , palystation,xbox.

    I would like to clarify that we have nothing to do with Sunshine Empire .All Sunshine Empire may look for my fuc-king wife about the re-fund of your investment money .

    Currently ,wwe offer to all Sunshine Empire member for FREE to convert their membership to Facebook,google,yahoo,baidu,skype,hotmail,alibaba.,youtube,gameboy , palystation,xbox.

    “We Will Be Stronger Ever That No Law Can Touch Us ”

    Regards,

    James Phang

  127. link says:

    No Law can touch shitman James phang last year …this year also same …. but only jail is waiting for him.At least 30 years …Rubbish guys …

  128. GRI Management says:

    Dear Our Valued Distributors,

    GRI will have a very good potnetial to increase the sales in China this year. Let us forget about Sunshine Empire and have a new start with GRI

    I would like to clarify that GRI have nothing to do with Sunshine Empire .All Sunshine Empire may look for Jackie Hoo about the re-fund of your investment money .

    Currently ,wwe offer to all Sunshine Empire member for FREE to convert their membership to GRI member.

    “GRI Will Be Stronger Ever That No Law Can Touch Us ”

    Regards,
    The Grand Royale International(GRI)Management Team
    James Phang

  129. Kenny Ong says:

    James Phang is really planning a grand CNY party at his own house .
    Can we gather all the victim (Sunshine Empire member) to go to James Phang house for our re-fund money ?
    James Phang seems that he will having another great year .

  130. F.J says:

    Currently,all Sunshine Empire members suffering but only James Phang who are now having a good life .Bought his son a nice BMW.Having great Chinese New Year party at his nice home .
    A lot of Sunshine Empire members not even have money to celebtare CNY . This is all caused by bastard James Phang .
    Where is justice ?

  131. link says:

    Sure no law can catch him now…see this year how??

  132. Ooi says:

    Last week, met James Phang at Hong
    Kong,GRI (Grand Royale International)meeting .
    He again promised 10 times the return to GRI member .
    He keep on mentioning : “No Law Can Touch Him “

  133. link says:

    Amway , Nuskin , E-Excel , Michael Jackson , Lady Gaga , is better then emmax …pls link this blog to all networking …let every body know about James Phang and Sunshine Empire .

  134. James Phang's Update says:

    Why still have people believe in bastard James Phang ?

    1) James Phang’s Sunshine Empire was closed down by Singapore Gavorment on 2007 .

    2) James Phang is now afraid to go to Thailand & Malaysia because he is in wanted list by Thailand Gavorment & Malaysia Gavorment .

    3) James Phang currently using GRI( Grand Royale International ) continue to scam people money at Hong Kong ,Dubai & China .

    If Sunshine Empire member want to take back you hard earn money ,go to this address to look for James Phang .

    Don’t go alone , go with large group of people .

    James Phang’s Office : 1 Coleman Street #06-07 ,The Adelphi ,Singapore 179803

    • jansher khan says:

      Are you sure he is scamming in HK?

      HK pple are not so easy to con.

      IKf he is caught, you can bet the gangsters there will send him back to singapore with arms & legs chop off.

  135. 发表于:2010-1-16 12:21:00

      虚构跨国投资标的传销在台吸金台币八千万
      在星、马、印尼、香港、台湾、中国等地进行多层次传销业务的阳光大帝公司,涉嫌以每月百分之十的高报酬获利招募会员投资。不过警方查出,集团宣称投资国外建案、网际网路,有部分是虚构的投资标的,在台湾违法吸金超过新台币八千万,刑事局将台湾分公司的吴姓负责人约谈到案,依诈欺罪嫌函送地检署侦办。
      刑事局调查,阳光大帝的彭姓创办人2006年7月在新加坡成立总公司,会员必须先缴交6300美金到7200美金成为「传销商」,才可取得电子积分,在公司网站购买保健、电器等产品,而且传销商只要招募下线,就可以获得电子积分,而累积的积分可换取现金或转卖他人套利。
      「阳光大帝」在新加坡成立之后,迅速向海外拓点,包括马来西亚、印尼、香港、台湾、中国、泰国等地设立分公司吸收会员,再以投资开发国外建案、网际网路科技公司等名义招揽会员,全球吸金超过四十一亿台币,但新加坡司法单位发现,集团对外宣称的马来西亚投资开发计画根本不存在,涉嫌违反公司法、做假帐、诈欺等罪名,今年二月将彭姓负责人等公司干部起诉。
      刑事局侦七队循线追查台湾分公司涉案部分,调查吴姓负责人2007年7月在台北市南京东路知名饭店召开投资说明会,以高报酬招募会员投资,并招待到海外旅游,宣称每个月可分得投资金额的百分之十为红利,成功介绍下线还可分得额外奖金。
      而在2007年11月新加坡总公司遭调查冻结资金期间,却对外宣布公司只是「改朝换代」,不受新加坡政府调查影响,继续招收会员,不过2008年1月最后一次发放红利给会员后,无预警在同年3月结束营业,导致上百名被害人求偿无门。
      警方表示,嫌犯以高报酬利诱投资人,而且放长线钓大鱼,一开始会如期发放红利,等到被害人尝到甜头一次投入大笔资金,公司就宣布倒闭,提醒投资民众,不要贪图丰厚利息,选择投资管道时,务必多听、多问公司经营方式是否为银行业者或经金管会核准特许,才不会血本无归

  136. how to convert ss/emmax to GRI, Nobody teach ??? this is big issue , cause all members suffered lost and hated James Phang ? some-more all the upline dont know where to go ? some upline already in jailed due to cannot bear the loan from bank. all suffered because of james phang .

  137. GRI Manageemnt says:

    Dear Our Valued Distributors,

    GRI will have a very good potnetial to increase the sales in China this year. Let us forget about Sunshine Empire and have a new start with GRI

    I would like to clarify that GRI have nothing to do with Sunshine Empire .All Sunshine Empire may look for Jackie Hoo about the re-fund of your investment money .

    Currently ,wwe offer to all Sunshine Empire member for FREE to convert their membership to GRI member.

    “GRI Will Be Stronger Ever which No Law Can Touch Us ”

    Regards,
    The Grand Royale International(GRI) (Management Team)
    James Phang

  138. GRI Manageemnt says:

    Dear Our Valued Distributors,

    GRI will have a very good potnetial to increase the sales in China this year. Let us forget about Sunshine Empire and have a new start with GRI.

    We offer to all Sunshine Empire member for FREE to convert their membership to GRI member.

    “GRI Will Be Stronger Ever which No Law Can Touch Us ”

    Regards,
    The Grand Royale International(GRI) (Management Team)
    James Phang

  139. Think First says:

    JP is in the wrong. But come to think of it, if the member themselves are no greedy, want to make money with minimum effort, do you think the scam will work? It take 2 hand to clap.

    I sincerely hope that the James Phang and all his Co-conman/conwoman should go jail too and all SE member get back their money. Even if can’t get back all, but aleast get back part of it. All these are their hardearn money.

  140. Terry Tan says:

    All Sunshime Empire’s member who want to meet James Phang may go to below address for your re-fund :
    The Adelphi,1 Coleman Street,#06-07,Singapore,178903.

  141. He will be in Jail soon,at least 20 years …. His bro in 缘中秀 predicted .

  142. Bernard Ong says:

    I and few of SE member visited JP office: The Adelphi,1 Coleman Street,#06-07,Singapore,178903.
    But James Phang not allow SE member to go inside his office .

  143. Johnson says:

    James Phang’s Update :
    1) Promoting his new scam in Hong Kong . GRI (Grand Royale International).
    2) Last November 2009,bought his son a new 5 Serious,BMW.
    3) Emcom earned a very good profit 2009 but did not pay Sunshine Empire’s member for the profit sharing.
    4) James Phang planing to have a great party at his own house onthis coming Chinese New Year 2010.
    5) James Phang have spend USD600,000 to renovate his office at : The Adelphi,1 Coleman Street,#06-07,Singapore,178903.

  144. Johnson says:

    James Phang’s Update :
    1) Promoting his new scam in Hong Kong . GRI (Grand Royale International).
    2) Last November 2009,bought his son a new 5 Serious,BMW.
    3) Emcom earned a very good profit 2009 but did not pay Sunshine Empire’s member for the profit sharing.
    4) James Phang planing to have a great party at his own house onthis coming Chinese New Year 2010.
    5) James Phang have spend USD600,000 to renovate his office at : The Adelphi,1 Coleman Street,#06-07,Singapore,178903.

  145. Hong Kong says:

    At Hong Kong GRI meeting January,2010 , James Phang have announced that “No Law Can Touch Him” .

    His GRI(Grand Royale International) business will be stronger ever .

  146. Singapore Merchant says:

    You really think James Phang will be going to jail ?
    The fact is : James Phang still on release and doing his GRI business in Hong Kong .Earning good money .
    You think Singapore CAD will care ?

  147. No way … Fuc-ker james phang and fuck-ket jackie will in jail soon , Court case is waiting for him this year , I guess he will be in jail at least minimum 20 years … This is what he conned members what he should pay for it.

  148. Victime says:

    To All Sunshine Empire Member ,
    At Hong Kong ,GRI’s (Grand Royale International )meeting,James Phang have clarified that he would not bare for any loss of Sunshine Empire .

    All Sunshine Empire’s member have signed the agreement that James Phang don’t have to responsible for any losses of their investment .

    James Phang also warning to all Sunshine Empire’s member,not to chase him about the re-fund money .He will report to the police if anyone who try to disturb him or his family.

  149. No way … he will in jail soon , Court case is waiting for him this year , I guess he will be in jail at least minimum 20 years … This is what he conned members what he should pay for it.

  150. SE Singapore says:

    For sure James Phang & his family member is having a very good life .
    All those money his family spend is the money he cheated from us .

  151. SE Singapore says:

    No way James Phang will refund our money .
    He even try to ignore all Sunshine Empire member.

  152. We must chase him about the re-fund money .He will not report to the police . He is in the blacklisted.

  153. SE Singapore says:

    What to do ? We have trusted the wrong idiot .
    Who willing to teach James Phang a lesson ?

  154. SE Singapore says:

    At Hong Kong ,GRI’s (Grand Royale International )meeting,James Phang have clarified that he would not bare for any loss of Sunshine Empire .

    All Sunshine Empire’s member have signed the agreement that James Phang don’t have to responsible for any losses of their investment .

    James Phang did also warning to all Sunshine Empire’s member,not to chase him about the re-fund money .He will report to the police if anyone who try to disturb him or his family.

  155. Pls remember . if he really invest and lost ,we can forgive him , but all the projects is none , just con money , we cannot forgive him …..no such projects at all. just con money and watch blue DVD with wife.

  156. SE Singapore says:

    At Hong Kong ,GRI’s (Grand Royale International )meeting,James Phang have clarified that he would not bare for any loss of Sunshine Empire .

    All Sunshine Empire’s member have signed the agreement that James Phang don’t have to responsible for any losses of their investment .

    James Phang did also warning to all Sunshine Empire’s member,not to chase him about the re-fund money .He will report to the police if anyone who try to disturb him or his family.

  157. fibonacci-split says:

    Not surprise that he surfaces in HK as his name stink in S’pore.

    If he smells in HK, he can move to China, a bigger market for him to con more people

    Our garmen give up on him oreaddy.

  158. EDWM Hengzzz says:

    James pHang was spotted in GRI(HK).

    I got the pictures from FB.

  159. Passerby says:

    After all the comments I read, everything is going up against ESA Trader. I think we can go to http://www.moneysense.gov.sg/news_events/Consumer_Portal_Latest_News.html that is a government web to check the truth. I had e-mail them asking about this ESA company. Any updates think I’ll update here again…

  160. SE Singapore says:

    Where is James Phang now ?

    How are we going to find him ?

  161. SE Singapore says:

    Few of James Phang’s company really in operation & earning well . All the earnnig goes into James Phang’s pocket .
    James Phang still don’t want to return our money what he scammed us .

  162. Dear Our Valued Distributors,
    亲爱的会员,

    Recently, we have observed several platforms NOT BELONGING to EmMax that are currently soliciting our distributors and clients and misrepresenting / carrying information of our company which is NOT ACCURATE.
    最近,本公司发现有几个不属于帝无限的平台正在极力利用本集团名誉误导我们的会员及客户,并且提供不确实的咨讯关于帝无限。

    We would greatly discourage our distributors and clients in taking any reference from the understated websites, and EmMax Limited shall not bear any legal or social responsibility for any personal harm or loss inflicted, should members or the general public choose to take actions based on the information perpetuated on these platforms.
    本公司绝不鼓励会员及客户凭着这些平台所提供的错误咨讯做出任何决定或选择。本公司也不会在法律或社会义务上,为自愿接触这些平台而遭受损失的会员或公众们负上任何责任。

    The platforms are:
    这些平台乃:

    http://www.gio-holdings.com
    http://www.marshall-link.com

    Our Official websites are as follow:
    正确网站乃以下网址:

    EmMax Homepage – http://www.em-max.com
    帝无限首页

    EmMax Distributor Login – 220.232.130.222/member
    帝无限会员登录

    SEANET Homepage – http://www.seanetinternational.com
    SEANET首页

    SEANET Distributor Login – 220.232.130.222/seanet
    SEANET 会员登录

    Regards,
    The EmMax Management Team
    帝无限管理层

    Posted on Mon, 4 Jan 2010

    • SeaNeter says:

      For your more information SeaNet Global Alliance is an independent company has no relation to any singaporian guy aor whatever james phang you are saying…seaNet is operated by benjamin Tan a guy from US by 20 years experience in MLM and Direct Selling and SeaNet is fully legal by Middle east UAE goverment…you guys are ballony tlaking always bullshit about anyone….

  163. ESA Trader says:

    Bank Negara warns of illegal currency trading scheme
    Jan 4, 10 12:33pm
    Bank Negara Malaysia has advised the public to not participate in any illegal investment or training programme on foreign currency trading offered by individuals or companies.

  164. Dont put your money under James Phang company , all cheated money .

  165. sohai says:

    LOL… LONG LIVE ESA!
    I’ve earned USD100K from ESA in just 4 months.
    Thanks for making me USD100k richer!

  166. 大骗子James Phang : 回头是岸,不要再害人了.啊弥陀佛

  167. Sg says:

    There is nothnig to do with govt .It is only the excuses for James Phang not to re-fund us.

    Currently ,James Phang’s business still in operation & earing well .

    1) SeaNet Global Alliance (SGA)
    2) Grand Royale Internaional (GRI)
    3) ESA Trader( Forex)
    4) Emcom (Taiwan)
    5) Niu Lifestyle (Singapore)
    6) Emmax ( Hong Kong)
    7) Grand Elitia (Hong Kong )

    All those company was build using Sunshine Empire member’s money .

    Now James Phang is getting richer and richer .

    But ….still James Phang don’t want to re-fund our money.

  168. Dxxkhead says:

    I am non-Esatrader investor, nor SunShine E. investor. Just my neutral opinion.
    Investors of ESA is puttin’ their $$$ into FXDD and not James Phang’s account. ESA just benefit from commision. As long as ESA program is profiting = investor withdraw anytime they like(as my frens did), then thats it. Thats relationship between customers and ESA. Nothing to do with Sunshine’s history shit. Losers love to bring all thing togtehr to be blame, such like ESA = Sunshine E.
    Russia is democratic country now, we cant judge it anymore like Stalin’s Communist era. If u unstd what i try to bring out.

  169. Sg says:

    There is nothnig to do with govt .It is only the excuses for James Phang not to re-fund us.

    Currently ,James Phang’s business still in operation & earing well .

    1) SeaNet Global Alliance (SGA)
    2) Grand Royale Internaional (GRI)
    3) ESA Trader( Forex)
    4) Emcom (Taiwan)
    5) Niu Lifestyle (Singapore)
    6) Emmax ( Hong Kong)
    7) Grand Elitia (Hong Kong )

    All those company was build using Sunshine Empire member’s money .

    Now James Phang is getting richer and richer .

    But ….still James Phang don’t want to re-fund our money.

  170. Sg says:

    Please .All the victim ,sunshine Empire’s member . We must do something .

    • SG says:

      we should ask the govt why extend the case for so long.

      we all having a very bad year from 2007, 2008 and 2009 already.

      why govt do not want to let the citizen to have a fruitful chinese new year.

      sad to have these type of govt.
      THEY ONLY THINK OF THEMSELF AND NOT THE CITIZEN.

      every year just giving sgd200.00 is enough or not.

      example: these month pay,dun need end of the mth govt all collect back already.

      we want our $$$$ back.

  171. Sg says:

    James Phang’s business still in operation & earning well .

    1) SeaNet Global Alliance (SGA) ,Dubai
    2) Grand Royale Internaional (GRI)
    3) ESA Trader( Forex)
    4) Emcom (Taiwan)
    5) Niu Lifestyle (Singapore)
    6) Emmax ( Hong Kong)
    7) Grand Elitia (Hong Kong )

    All those company was builded using Sunshine Empire member’s money .

    Now James Phang is getting richer and richer .All Sunshine Empire member’s get suffer .

  172. Sg says:

    James Phang’s EGA (Empire Group of Alliance) have changed their name to SeaNet Global Alliance (SGA)in Dubai .
    SeaNet is now earning very good and all money goes into James Phang’s pocket .
    James Phang still insist not to pay back our money.
    Curse him . Curse his whole family.

  173. victim says:

    We must do something . At least James Phang still have money to celebrate X’mas and CNY .
    But we can’t caused by stupid James Phang.

  174. reverse flick says:

    You want to take back your $$$?

    Easy.

    Round uo a few guys. Go to his house at 259 Westwood Ave at about 3am in the morning & sing christmas carol………….

  175. thane says:

    Haha, after reading all the comments, I would like to conclude this:

    1)I don’t know who is James Phang, but I am sure he is a mother fucker.

    2)I am an experience full time trader, I trade futures, forex and commodity MANUALLY. You will not scam by ESA Trader because the money is NOT with them, it is between you and FXDD, for your information, FXDD is about to be regulated by NFA.

    BUT, you will have the risk of losing money, IF the EA not perform well. Please do not blame ESA Trader as I believed they tried their best to make the EA to perform. Forex trading is NOT for everyone UNLESS you know what is RISK MANAGEMENT.

    TAKE NOTE, ESA trader made money for every trade that the EA have entered, they will charge you USD6 no matter that particular trade win or lose, that is their business model and they earn money from there. As a return, they will make sure the EA can earn money or else they will bankrap.

    3)I pitty real Andy, the CEO of Esa Trader, I suggest you to do the following in order to save your business:
    a)Fire Terry Tan as your account advisor, you and I know he wants to make profit from forex commisen given by you, but his pass history is just too bad, he will make you lost your business in long run, you should know the power of internet forum and mouth-to-mouth rumour spread. If possible fire anyone that related to sunshine empire.

    3)People’s GREED. I would say NONE of the people posting here can be a REAL TRADER. I can see the ugly part of human being. Please go and find a proper job, no easy money my friends.

    4)Go to hell James Phang.

    5)Go to hell James Phang.

    6)Good Luck in your business Andy :)

    Bye bye

  176. James Phang's Victim says:

    To James Phang ,
    Please give us back our hard earn money .Without the money our family can not celebrate this coming X’mas & CNY 2010 .
    We are really in deep financial problem .Please re-fund our money .

  177. reverse flick says:

    Have you all SE victims watch You Tube.

    You can catch our mentor, JP, dancing in Genting. He seems to be quite talented for a man with 2 left feet. His body want to move to the left but his legs goes to the right.

    Anyway, after the Authority got rid of Clement Chiang, JP will be next on the chopping board. I’m excited to see him book his hotel room in Changi

  178. Reader says:

    ESA member’s so likely to comment in here .Which mean ESA Trader really another James Phang’s scam .
    Be careful . ESA Trader can be closed down anytime .

  179. Tan Ah Teik says:

    SIMPLE AS THAT , USE YOUR COMMON SENSE, THE MONEY PROFITED IS DIRECTLY FROM THE FOREX MARKET, IT’S NOT LIKE SUNSHINE EMPIRE’S MONEY MERRY GO ROUND BUSINESS.

    SO CARRY ON WITH YOUR GOOD WORK ESA.
    THOSE NOT AGREE PLEASE CLOSED YOUR ACCOUNT, TAKE BACK YOUR MONEY AND GO, DONT DISTURB, OK?

  180. ESA Member says:

    Inside ESA Trader got so many problem . I and my friend will put out out investment .
    We don’t trust the scammer : Terry Tan as well .
    He have caused a lot of people loss money and he run away .

  181. HT.Tan says:

    ESA Trader people only know to talk big .
    A lot of member really loss their investment and still trying to hide the truth.
    ESA management is very messy . Always change their regulation and direction to mis-lead members .ESA internally got a lot of problem already.
    Why still believe on they ?

  182. SSE says:

    Anti James Phang is Monkey Ass .
    Ha..ha…..

  183. SSE says:

    Michael Lee is a monkey .
    Ha..ha…..

  184. Dear Michael Lee,

    Your comments really give a good eye opening to everyone here. My advice is that no point explaining to a bunch of monkeys out there. Let hopeless remain hopeless. I too anti James Phang but life goes on…

  185. Lee says:

    I agree .
    Michael Lee only tell good thing about ESA Trader . The truth/bad side of ESA Trader he afraid to tell .He can not be trusted . Scammer’s talking style.Talk big .
    His tiny head got problem.

  186. Gary says:

    ESA Trader sending Michael Lee to advertise in here again .
    Somethig very wrong about ESA Trader & Michael Lee .
    Causing a lot of member loss money and now talk big in here .

  187. Michael Lee says:

    KY, if you have not noticed, you have only antagonized yourself and nobody else. What you said publicly only reflects your state of mind and maturity. I am not bothered by what you said and not even bothered to return to this blog. I came to seek the truth to find if there is any proof that my money can be cheated by FXDD and ESA Trader – I too influenced by rumours. I was very concerned if JP is behind ESA Trader. I have not found any clue of fraud yet. I even spoke to FXDD about PAMM and they confirmed its their systems to put in bigger lot of order and later redistribute to the many investor according to their equity participation. Simple as that. Not a system invented as some claimed to cheat the investor of their money. I had a good laugh after I found the truth from FXDD.
    Those who wants the truth can always go to FXDD.com website and od a live chat with them and ask them any question. Now that my money is safe I dont care who is behind the company.Thats is my personal choice and opinion and I dont encourage anybody to follow my decision.

  188. Michael Lee says:

    I will not put the good educaton my parent gave me to waste by engaging in public debate using unkind wowords. My intention is noble to tell the truth as least from my side of the experience. If there are
    others who have different experience they should tell share their experience and not make wild allegations.
    I write for those with eyes to see, those with a clear mind to comprehend and those who wish to seek the truth/facts find the truth. A paper is White and we can paint any colour on it as we like. We can makea situation as good or as bad as we want it – its all in our mind.
    Those who are clouded by anger prejudices should stop reading this blog if you cannot accept truth. And this is the last I am going to contribute becuase we need not write too many times. Those who seek truth will find truth and those who are blind will always be blind. Wisdom is not a previlege everybody has.
    Hopefully those who has use them well. There are probably at least 100 other companies doing what ESA Trader is doing just with differing level of success. Those who cant trade or no time to trade uses their services for a fee per trade. Dont like just terminate their services, simple ss that. They survive on continuing making successful trades. So those people who try to destroy them dont really have to do anything. Because if you claim they lost alot of investor money, they will die a natural death within months. Why waste your energy and time?
    Again this is for those who seak the truth to read. In any case, if you ever hss any doubt in anything just stay away. Why take the risk?

  189. Gary says:

    This site is actually for anti-scammer & anti-James Phang .
    ESA Trader & stupid Michael Lee so likely to promote ESA Trader in here .
    Which mean ,ESA Trader & Michael Lee really have relation with James Phang(scammer)

  190. Ky.Lim says:

    Stupid Michael Lee ( ESA Trader’s member ) trying to promote their scam in here .

  191. Ky.Lim says:

    Michael Lee trying to promte ESa Trader in here again . I guess ESA Trader have no money to advertist.
    Something wrong about ESA Trader .Many member facing a lot of loss .Cheated .

  192. Michael Lee says:

    Additional comment on ESA or FXDd.

    I came to theis blog to find out any proof of fraud or cheat by FXDD or ESA Trader. I didnt read any that prove that – just wild allegations, hearsay and sinister plot to destroy ESA because of perceived JP involvement. I dont know really if JP is involved. I want to see proof of fraud then I stop my investment. Right now we have been able to withdraw money on our own free will even without consultation with ESA but of course in doing so we face the danger of hitting margin call but really, nobody can stop you withdrawing your money. My friend asked me to show account that loses money. I want to but there is any. There are those who lost money in the first 2 week consecutively hit with 3 tmes 300pips loss, invested $4000 lost $3,600 but at the end of 6 weeks still profitted 120%. So those who said lost money in first week or second week did not tell the whole story. Or it is NOT EVEN their story so they dont have all the facts. For me who dared to write, i can show the proof. Forex is high risk investment. On my own, I lost 100% in 3 days. On Robot Trade I made money everyday – how lucky can I be. Again, I have no business to defend ESA Trader but I offer a balance, fair view and the TRUTH. For those who were cheated stay away from any kind of big return investment and you will be safe – especailly those that you have to hand money over to a company you hardly know nor established. ESA do not handle my money, just my trade. FXDD is big and if it has to go bankrupt like Lehman Bro then,just my luck, what to do?. So we keep withdrawing our profit as we profitted. Many of us already got 50-100% of our capital back. We all have to pay in one way or another for our wrong doing. So again, its not easy to forget the bad experience of being cheated especially if it made you in heavy indebtedness or bankruptcy. But if you forget and move on, you probably get better energy to do well in your life not to let the past to continually haunt you. You paid the prize, now benefit from the lesson. Not to pay even more prize by suffering mentally and emotionally.

  193. Michael Lee says:

    Let me state my position so that my comments can be digested with an open mind and fairly – not for any particular group of person’s benefit but for those who are objective. I am just an investor with ESA Trader who joined with a group of about 20 other friends. I turned my friend away when first asked to listen to what ESA Trader has done for them giving them phenomenal profit. My first reaction is anything with such impressive return must be a scam or fraud. It was until another friend approach me one month later that I decided to go and listen to the proview with the sole objective of ‘saving’ my friend from this scam. I personally paidRM4,900 to attend one of the top Forex class in town and has benefitted and learnt a great deal about Forex,all except making profit. My fellow students had similar experience – sound knowledge but we cant make money. After the preview, I was thinking how could ESA practice of 300pips stoploss which is totally against what our trainer taught us cold possibly make them money. So a group of us tested it out on demo accounts and bingo we made money. With that confidence and further discussion amongst us that neither FXDD or ESA Trader could in anyway cheat us of our money, we decided to give it a shot since the amount involved isn’t too big – I have already lost that much on my own trade anyway. We profitted anything from 20-98% within 1 month. Nobody in my group losses any money – just some profit more and some less. These are truth, not hearsay or wild allegation. I have no business to defend or promote ESA but I symphathise with those bent on destroying this company bcoz of their anger with JP and by extension their assumption of ESA with JP. I dont know who JP is but as an investor we did our due deligence. We checked out FXDD, We confirmed with friends who withdrew money that they got it back into their account within 3 days. ESA Trader only has control over our trading which could be stopped anytime. Whoever JP is and if it were true he is behind ESA Trader, personally it does not bother me so long he has no means of cheating my money. As soon as performance falter or dropped, we will terminate ESA service asap. I never get myself involved with those big return stuff promised by Sunshine Empire or Gold outfit – I never believe that return can be that good for an operation we cannot understand. But I believe in Forex and ESA is just a oonvenient and reliable vehicle for now. The momment they cannot perform, we terminate their service. As for fraud, I hope somebody can elaborate how FXDD or ESA can cheat their client in this Forex deal. Seriously I want to know, not just some wild allegations or personal opinion. I repeat I have no business to defend or promote ESA, at least not to you people whom I dont know. But i do promote to my friends and family whom I care about to make that extra cash which turn out to be very lucrative actually. For those who were cheated, let that be a lesson well learnt and let the authorities deal witht he culprit. Get on with your life and do not harbour any anger or you will let real opportunities pass you by in future just because of one bad experience. I paid a big prize myself in the 1993/94 and 97/98 and 2001 Stock Market crash. We grow we learn and I hope those who suffered, learnt too. When you curse someone, you built up alot of negative energy which is not good for health or your mind.
    I share in good faith and hope to bless someone.

  194. Low says:

    There are so many Forex company in the market . ESA Trader is the worst .
    Money can not withdraw .

  195. KY.Lim says:

    Michael Lee trying to promote ESA in here .
    He always tell the good things. The truth/bad thing of ESA Trader he afraid to tell .
    A lot of people loss their money in ESA trader he never tell.

  196. Careful Sam says:

    Just a piece of cautionary advice to everyone ‘playing’ in EsaTrader…please note that recently they are coming up with all kinds of new rules and regulations like even imposing a quota on Malaysian traders by not allowing them to join as from the first Dec 2009 but only opening up to them again from 2010 onwards.Why should someone in business like Esatrader turn to imposing quotas when every new business from every corner of the world should benefit them….think about this and be weary and also be cautious about their excuse with every new development they announce on their website that they are working round the clock to overcome this and that problem, that always seem to crop up. How can like this?

  197. Michael Lee says:

    I dont know who James Phang is and obviously alot of people sore with him for being cheated. There are poeple who linked ESA Trader with JP. But my personal experience with ESA Trader and my knowledge of Forex has been these. My money is with FXDD, not with ESA Trader so there is no way it can scam away my money. They survive on making profitable trades for me and they have been doing so. I have with me accounts of more than 15 people who joined my group – we made average of 20-985 within 1 month. Thats a sterling performance by any standard for Forex. If its fluke that they can do so I take my hats off. I went to Forex school paid $4900 and lost almost 100% of my money. In the last month, I invested $3000 with FXDD and asked ESA Trader to trade and made 70% in one month and this is the truth. One fren made 35% in 1 week. Automated Forex trading is very common in the net and ESA Trader has been very good or very lucky to get all my friends to make profit this first month.

    I wish somebody can expose the scam to me….I still cannot see it.

  198. KY.Lim says:

    Luckly I did not join ESA Trader becuase my friends loss 60% of their money within 1 week .

  199. KY.Lim says:

    Luckly I did not join ESA Trader becuase my friends all 60% of their money within 1 week .

  200. curious says:

    few of my frens keep on asking me to join ESA, not so sure about that company, i just feel something is not right. Maybe I am chicken :)

  201. John says:

    All of my frieds already pull out from ESA Trader . ESA Trader really related with James Phang . Not safe . Can be closed anytime .

  202. Dear All :
    If possible , dont invest this fund not approved by goverment..all cheat people money . i suffered a lots after invest sunshine empire .

  203. Richard says:

    Fair advice man. Keep your investments safe, think long term. Don’t pay someone $20K for some short term miracle!

  204. anti-scammer says:

    Terry Tan (ESA Trader) is one of the top scammer in Singapore . He is now using Forex (ESA Trader) to scam people .
    A lot of his victim still looking for him .

    • sad lady says:

      r u sure esatrader is manage by tery tan? is tery tan so power?.i hopetery tan will approach infront of people saying that he is not the esatrder management.this young i seen before,
      he echo n show off.better ask him come out see people,useless person.

  205. Dont Joint any forex or Trader by James Phang ,

  206. jackie says:

    LOL…

    what’s wrong with you guys?

    If you are talking about PAMM account from fxdd,i have been using it for some times to manage my client’s fund.

    It’s a common methodology being implement by master forex traders.

    You guys new to forex?

    • PAMM? says:

      I am familar with PAMM.
      1.Do you know as long as there are floating losses, the client signed under PAMM will not able to withdraw money until the master account closes all trades. You no longer can stop the account from trading as before.

      2.And it also means that all accounts under the PAMM has one single entry and exit points. This is dangerous as the broker can play them out with visible pending stop losses.

      3.Eventhough, over a 3 to 6 month period, on an average the ‘fund’ has been doing well. But this is on the average, meaning if your friends come in on the month that is losing money… let say 40% losses, it will take the fund to grow closes to 70% the following month to get it back to 100% again as the fund has shrinked.

  207. david says:

    of course!!! he is rushing to HOLLAND celebrate christmas with JAMES PHANG

  208. grace says:

    Wah!!! you mean the PAMM account they are talking about is the trick?? Nowonder terry push me everyday to sign the form joint their bus la..

  209. david says:

    Attention to all ESATRADERS members,
    FINAL PLAN of JAMES PHANG: 4 million USD with 4 bus going to holland!!!
    now he ask all traders authorise their fund to him, & bring those 4 bus to holland trade forex..
    Beware!!! this 4 bus wont return, dont be the passenger!!!
    THIS IS THE WAY HE CHEAT, DONT BE CHEATED BY HIM AGAIN..
    ESA management always turn their story, this is their final trip, then JAMES PHANG will take our money to enjoy his wonderful life

  210. sad lady says:

    better cal fucker james phang go to the hell
    and die faster with his wife.pls cal tery tan don’t join esatrader,stay in the jungle.don’t expose in front of people.害人害己。

  211. James Phang is a shamful guys ….江洋大盗 ….该死,骗人血汗钱.

    http://sgfraud.blogspot.com/2009_10_01_archive.html

    Monday, October 5, 2009
    Sunshine Empire 2 – the charges

    From the Commercial Affairs Department website – as at 5 October 2009

    Q What is the status of the investigation?
    A CAD has completed the investigations on Sunshine Empire Pte Ltd (“Sunshine Empire”) and other companies involved in this case. On 3 February 2009, the following persons have been charged in the Subordinate Court.

    a. Jackie Hoo Choon Cheat, a director of Sunshine Empire, and James Phang Wah each faced 1 charge of fraudulent trading under Section 340 of the Companies Act, 1 charge of failure to maintain proper accounting records of Sunshine Empire under Section 199 of the Companies Act and 8 charges of criminal breach of trust as an agent of Sunshine Empire under Section 409 of the Penal Code;

    b. James Phang Wah also faced 6 charges of falsification of Sunshine Empire’s accounts under Section 477A of the Penal Code and 1 charge of false declaration of the share capital of Empire Communications Technology Pte Ltd under Section 401 (2A) (b) of the Companies Act. In addition to the Penal Code and Companies Act charges, James Phang Wah faced 3 charges for possession of uncensored and obscene films under the Films Act;

    c. Neo Kuon Huay, a director of Empire Emall (S) Pte Ltd, faced 6 charges of falsification of Sunshine Empire’s accounts under Section 477A of the Penal Code and 1 charge of false declaration of the share capital of Empire Emall (S) Pte Ltd under Section 401 (2A) (b) of the Companies Act; and

    d. Yong Wai Hong, a director of Empire Communications Technology Pte Ltd and various companies, faced 6 charges of false declaration of the share capital of various companies under Section 401 (2A) (b) of the Companies Act.

    Note that Yong Wai Hong has already been convicted of the charges under the Companies Act.
    Posted by TTan at 6:36 PM 0 comments
    Labels: Ponzi scheme
    Sunshine Empire trial

    The trial of the bosses of the Sunshine Empire has just started. James Phang, his wife Neo Kuon Huay, and ex-direcror Jackie Hoo Choon Cheat have been charged with their roles in this affair.

    The prosecution has alleged that they masterminded what is Singapore’s largest Ponzi scheme involving more than $180 million. Ponzi schemes are a scam where monies from new investors is used to pay off previous investors, thus giving the appearance of a successful business model.In this way, more investments are attracted.

    Ponzi schemes have been in the news in the last 12 months because of the enormous scam run by American Bernie Madoff. Please search this blog if you want more information on some of Madoff’s tactics.
    Posted by TTan at 6:25 PM 0 comments
    Labels: Fraud methods, Ponzi scheme

  212. Emmax Said other company is scam as below :

    本公司绝不鼓励会员及客户凭着这些平台所提供的错误咨讯做出任何决定或选择。本公司也不会在法律或社会义务上,为自愿接触这些平台而遭受损失的会员或公众们负上任何责任。

    The platforms are:
    这些平台乃:

    http://www.gio-holdings.com
    http://www.marshall-link.com
    現在就加入Emmax,將生命發揮到極致!

    ( After jointed Emmax : Eat , Drink , Happy , Drive Mercedez Benz –> James Phang . Poor and Suffer Lost –> Emmax Members )

    gio-holdings, marshall-link is scam. Emmax is NOT scam ???

  213. 為21世紀最具有活力的商業機遇做好準備!

    緊跟消費趨勢,利用持續增長的經濟和網路的力量,帝無限的革命性商業模式幫助了世界範圍內數以千計的人士獲取了美麗、健康與財富。

    現在就加入Emmax,將生命發揮到極致!

  214. System undergo maintanence 系统需进行维护
    Dear Valued Distributors,
    亲爱的会员,

    Please note that the system administrator have request the system to undergo maintanence on 6th Nov 2009 at 12am in order to serve you better. The system will be back to normal on 9th Nov
    2009. We apologise for any inconveniences that has arised during the course of the system maintenance.
    由于公司系统需进行维护,故将于二零零九年十一月六日凌晨十二时起暂停运作,并预计于二零零九年十一月九日恢复服务。我们也再次对这次系统进行维护所带来的不便之处至万分的抱歉。

    The EmMax Management Team
    帝无限管理层

    Posted on Fri, 6 Nov 2009

    November ERI deadline 十一月份无限消费奖励截止日期
    Dear Our Valued Distributors,
    亲爱的会员,

    The management has decided to extend the November ERI deadline to 5th December 2009. You are encouraged to take advantage in these extra days in your effort to achieve outstanding sales result for the month.

    公司现将二零零九年十一月份无限消费奖励之截数日延止二零零九年十二月五日,请各会员把握时间争取更佳销售业绩!

    Regards,
    The EmMax Management Team
    帝无限管理层

    Posted on Fri, 6 Nov 2009

    NLS Operation Guide 新脉动经营手册
    Dear Our Valued Distributors,
    亲爱的会员,

    We are pleased to inform you that the NLS Operation Guide is ready. Please refer to the “Downloads” section for the details.

    我们很高兴的向您宣布新脉动经营手册已完成。会员可在“下载”地区下载此文件。

    Regards, The EmMax Management Team
    帝无限管理层

    Posted on Fri, 6 Nov 2009

    Products temporary out-of-stock 产品/配套暂时缺货
    Dear Our Valued Distributors,
    亲爱的会员,

    Due to the overwhelming respond in recent weeks, the following products are temporary out-of-stock. You are advised not to redeem any such product(s) or SE or GM with any of the following combination for the time being.
    由于近期过渡热烈的市场反应与需求,以下产品/配套暂时缺货。本公司建议您暂时避免领取以下产品,或掺有以下产品的配套,以免物流记录出错。

    1. Pure Whitening Set Puré 美白护理套装
    2. Pure Wrinkle Set Puré 抗衰老及抗皱套装
    3. Pure Hydration Set Puré 超敏感润泽套装
    4. Pure Oil Control Set Puré 抗粉刺控油套装
    5. Quick Shape
    6. SE9 “Live-Laugh-Happy” 生活,笑容,幸福 首饰
    7. SE10 “Cherish” 珍惜
    8. GM14 “Fung Shui Item 风水物

    We will notify you as soon as the stocks are available.
    本公司会在货物到齐的最快时间内通知您。

    Regards,
    The EmMax Management Team
    帝无限管理层

    Posted on Fri, 6 Nov 2009

    IMPORTANT NOTICE 重要通告
    Dear Our Valued Distributors,
    亲爱的会员,

    Recently, we have observed several platforms NOT BELONGING to EmMax that are currently soliciting our distributors and clients and misrepresenting / carrying information of our company which is NOT ACCURATE.
    最近,本公司发现有几个不属于帝无限的平台正在极力利用本集团名誉误导我们的会员及客户,并且提供不确实的咨讯关于帝无限。

    We would greatly discourage our distributors and clients in taking any reference from the understated websites, and EmMax Limited shall not bear any legal or social responsibility for any personal harm or loss inflicted, should members or the general public choose to take actions based on the information perpetuated on these platforms.
    本公司绝不鼓励会员及客户凭着这些平台所提供的错误咨讯做出任何决定或选择。本公司也不会在法律或社会义务上,为自愿接触这些平台而遭受损失的会员或公众们负上任何责任。

    The platforms are:
    这些平台乃:

    http://www.gio-holdings.com
    http://www.marshall-link.com

    Our Official websites are as follow:
    正确网站乃以下网址:

    EmMax Homepage – http://www.em-max.com
    帝无限首页

    EmMax Distributor Login – 220.232.130.222/member
    帝无限会员登录

    SEANET Homepage – http://www.seanetinternational.com
    SEANET首页

    SEANET Distributor Login – 220.232.130.222/seanet
    SEANET 会员登录

    Regards,
    The EmMax Management Team
    帝无限管理层

  215. Jon says:

    It seem that many out here have a very childish thinking. Does it mean that when u see many ex-SE member in ESA means that it belongs to James Phang too? When SE held their convention in Genting means that Genting belong to James Phang too? I also see many members from different MLM company so does it mean that James Phang owned them all? I dare to tell u all that many are victims of Sunshine Empire.

    For all the people that join ESA, their money are with FXDD. So does it mean that he wons FXDD too? Wake up guys, FXDD exist before Sunshine Empire was even born. So hope u know how to use your brain when do the talking, not with your little head down there.

  216. old emmax says:

    It is impossible that Ex-sunshine Empire in ESA Trader’s meeting.

    the reason below:
    1) For ex-member (man) , All hated James Phang , When see JP . All use Dog , Cat to fu-ck his ass-hole until he go to hell.

    2) For em-member (women) , All use cucumber to fu-ck his mother fu-cker ass-hole until he dies.

  217. Malaysia says:

    It is really funny to see all Ex-SE scammers barking here in this blog.

    You put money into SE because of your stupidity and belief of money can be raised our of thin air and now barking everywhere on this matter.

    All SE members should slapped yourself really hard for your simple and stupid mind ..and not to mention your GREED.

    No one point a gun at you to invest in SE previously too.

    IT’S YOUR GREEDY STUPID MIND. GO BLAME URSELF RATHER THAN OTHER PPL.

  218. ESA Member says:

    Is it true ESA Trader is James Phang company ?
    I really did met a lot of Ex-sunshine Empire in ESA Trader’s meeting.
    Somethings very wrong in ESA Trader.

  219. God.. says:

    James Phang : 回头是岸,不要再害人了.

  220. sad lady says:

    is esatrader belongs to bugger james phang.
    r u have evidence to prove it,tery tan thsi youngster,is he brave infront of people coming chet people money.grand royale will be open office at jan cheras,(bearby loke yew.)now,bugger james phang
    is the big boss n start cheating malay market.
    pls tell your frinds be careful.is dr andy low one gang with them.i am not believe because he is educated person not loke them.u can call tery tan
    or infront of him and ask whether he is gang with bugger james phang….hopefully he will go to the hell and see YAN LOW HWANG

  221. he is Still hiding at home watching and playing x dvd .

  222. kim says:

    isnt james phang is the jail now???

  223. Yes … hate mother fuc-ker James Phang and His gang Terry and Andy . Shamful . Just know to con members money , We put our hard earn money to him .But he just said projects failed and shut down emmax/se . That why we need our money back , cannot let this kind of people freedom . Must in Jail forever.

  224. Yellow Submarine says:

    This blog has simply turned into a hate all forum and from the grammar presented,this new Dr Andy Lau doing the posts now certainly is not the same as the learned professor because this bugger does not seem to be able to coin two proper words in english to save his life,anyone can tell.Please do not be mistaken,the internet does not exist in a vacuum.You can be charged for any number of internet crimes when you can be traced by your IP address and it goes the same for the owner of this blog too who does not seem to take any trouble to moderate.

  225. SE says:

    Be Aware !! Scam Compnay :
    1) ESA Trader ( Dr.Andy.L.Y.Low, James Phang,Ken Lee & Terry Tan)
    2) Grand Royale International (James Phang)
    3) Grand Elitia (Jackie Hoo,Terry Tan & Ken Lee )

  226. Mother Fuc-ker James Phang , Terry , Dr. Andy should go to jail forever , They con members money.

  227. JJ says:

    Dr.andy L.Y.Low must be brain sick . Maybe he study too much already. He just want to con people’s money .
    A lot of people don’t like him .He like to give empty promises .Talk big .
    Dr.Andy always go to Hatyai .

  228. To Whom It May Concern:
    1) James Phang still watched X DVD at home yesterday night .
    2) We played 6P ( James Phang & wife , Terry & wife , me and dog ).
    3) James Phang Pen-nis changed to small after conned emmax/se members , only 1mm lenght but width 50mm.
    4)If anyone purchase ESA trader , He pen-nis might same as mother fuc-ker Janes Phang .
    Best Regards
    Andy

  229. Toh says:

    To all trader ,
    Be very careful .
    1) 40% of ESA member are from Sunshine Empire(James Phang) & Grand Elitia .
    2) Dr. Andy L. Y. Low do not allow people to tell the truth about ESA Trader .
    3) Dr. Andy L. Y. Low had recruited scammer Terry Tan (Sunshine Empire’s scammer) as his Account Advisor.
    4) ESA Trader have very nice website but do not have real office in Asia .
    5) ESA Trader using MLM method but without having the MLM lisence from goverment.
    6) The boss behind ESA Trader very high possiblility is James Phang.
    7) FXDD is well known as not reliable broker .
    CEO of ESA Trader (Dr.Andy ) like to talk big , showing off & acting dump.James Phang’s talking style .
    9) Dr.Andy afraid to put thier management name in their website.Try to hide it from members.
    10) Few of the trader had complaint they loss a lot of money & can not withdraw their money .
    11) 18% of ESA Trader member already left ESA Trader due to Dr.Andy never kept his word . Empty promises.
    12) ESA Trader: When earning ,Dr.Andy takes all the profit.when loss of money ,member bare all the losses.(Exactly same as Sunshine Empire’s scam)

  230. foo says:

    To everybody,
    Becareful of Toh. He seems to know so much of James Phang & Sunshine Empire and I suspect that he got something to do with Sunshine Empire & James Phang. Now he is trying to act innocent n push everything to others. Don’t trust this guy!

  231. Hope Justice Be Brought says:

    What’s the registered company name for ESA Trader in Singapore?
    I cant seem to find it.

  232. Toh says:

    To all trader ,
    Be very careful .
    1) 40% of ESA member are from Sunshine Empire(James Phang) & Grand Elitia .
    2) Dr. Andy L. Y. Low do not allow people to tell the truth about ESA Trader .
    3) Dr. Andy L. Y. Low had recruited scammer Terry Tan (Sunshine Empire’s scammer) as his Account Advisor.
    4) ESA Trader have very nice website but do not have real office in Asia .
    5) ESA Trader using MLM method but without having the MLM lisence from goverment.
    6) The boss behind ESA Trader very high possiblility is James Phang.
    7) FXDD is well known as not reliable broker .
    CEO of ESA Trader (Dr.Andy ) like to talk big , showing off & acting dump.James Phang’s talking style .
    9) Dr.Andy afraid to put thier management name in their website.Try to hide it from members.
    10) Few of the trader had complaint they loss a lot of money & can not withdraw their money .
    11) 18% of ESA Trader member already left ESA Trader due to Dr.Andy never kept his word . Empty promises.
    12) ESA Trader: When earning ,Dr.Andy takes all the profit.when loss of money ,member bare all the losses.(Exactly same as Sunshine Empire’s scam)

  233. kim says:

    to DR.Andy
    is that really u Dr andy? im curious as all the previous comments posted by u kept on mentioning that u do not know James Phang but now u said u met him last week and as well as saying a few projects were conning people, but what makes me feel suspicious is ur grammar doesnt seem same as b4, are u a faker?
    pls be liable of what u did

  234. Hi all :
    1) If you joint ESA , We guarantee 1000% return.
    2)I had discussed with James Phang last week , James Phang promise to return all OEM points + 10 times profit in next generation.
    3)Not every projects we con people , just few projects .if you still not unclear ,kindly email me.
    [email protected]

    • kim says:

      i can certainly confirm that this guy is a faker, his grammar is bad compare to the real Dr Andy
      pls dun be fool by this faker

    • To Whom It May Concern,

      I received emails asking for OEM points in which only I realised that someone posted something which is not from me. In this case, I will call it a hoax. I have no idea who did it but please do not do such thing. It just proved my comments that the comments from this blog are from unknown sources and the information is not reliable. Readers are therefore strongly advised to verify its authenticity and process it carefully.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Andy

  235. kim says:

    majority people here were saying of what 40% of ESA traders staff from SE, and a lot of figure work, but i am wondering that these statements have not evidence, everyone just saying it is a scam but DR andy has mentioned of ESA trader is not a broker but only a service provider of their autotrading software,sincere hope people around here read the comments chariness and without bias

  236. bizman says:

    u guys are so not forex traders at all. if money is directed/deposited at the broker. then why kpkb? scam where?*look around* . u guys are such whiners..losers.~! i hate JP as well but..get some facts right man…if someone or some organisation without proper constituition handles ur money..Prepare for it to be gone. Grow up! u guys are so new to investing your brains are probably up your arses. I dont see a problem in this as long money goes into something that is verified as a living body organisation. You still have control over your account. This is Forex mt4 platform where u have control and transparency. But YES..u guys talk about Gainsfx , eforexcity all that…Dont join!!!! Dangerous people..They claim to have the best investor on their side with no proper registration n license to operate!!! Brothers..Think…i think we got more brains to think than our mouth blabber with anger right? =)

  237. Angel S says:

    Hi All,Just get this clear that I’m not on either side,just a passer-by who came along this blog.

    I actually did some checking and I found out that James Phang DOES NOT belong to ESA Trader.Sunshine Empire was his and people like him who scam other people’s money wil surely have their retributions.

    I also checked on Terry Tan.He DOES NOT work for Sunshine Empire.I don’t know if he was a victim of Sunshine Empire(as in those who invested) but I checked he is now a student of Esa Trader.He also DOES NOT work for Esa Trader.But he is one of those who invested and believe in this automated trading platform,and spreading the word around to his friends,which is similar to being an Account Advisor.But he definitely DOES NOT hold any share with Esa Trader group of directors.

    Hope this information helps to clarify.

  238. Abgel S :
    You are right .
    1)James Phang con members money, so what ?
    2)Why all SE/EM member jointed without checked properly , All of SE/EM members are stupid.
    3)Eventhough singapore Goverment also cannot do anything , what you all stupid member you do ?

  239. Angel S says:

    What goes around comes around. For ALL those above who has spoken ill of others will receive bad in other ways. Heaven have eyes so watch what you bad-mouth about others. Whatever is real is judgemental in your own eyes. It’s what you choose to believe in. Those who are reading this blog–Do u seriously believe whatever bad things being said here is true? DO NOT believe what others had said,mouth is theirs,hands are theirs,they can say and type anything they want.Instead,im just basis on logical facts and a clear conscience to tell you-if you wish to find out the truth, go find out on paper in BLACK & WHITE.People who have done bad,said bad will see Blackness in their life.People who have done good,said good will see Pureness in their life.I’m only stating the facts.If you don’t want bad things to happen to yourself,then don’t do it to others.

  240. hot mail says:

    What happend to singapore gorverment ? still keep silence ? Until now still let still kind of people freedom ? Where is the law now??? all kia shi and kia shu ? Please think all singaporean , this is your money , you must take back your hard earn money. your heart not feeling painted due to some outsider con your family money ? still keep silence?
    I hope all singapore se/emmax do something . you are very closed to him compare malaysia and thailand..

  241. Scam says:

    ESA Trader & GRI(Grand Royole International) belong to James Phang .
    Don’t join .
    Scam company.

  242. hot mail says:

    What happend to singapore gorverment ? still keep silence ? Until now still let still kind of people freedom ? Where is the law now??? all kia shi and kia shu ? Please think all singaporean , this is your money , you must take back your hard earn money. your heart not feeling painted due to some outsider con your family money ? still keep silence?
    I hope all singapore se/emmax do something . you are very closed to him compare malaysia and thailand.

  243. Anti-SE says:

    Now James Phang sending Jackie Hoo,Ken Lee,Terry Tan & Dr.Andy L.Y.Low(ESA Trader) to con more poeple .

    • anti game says:

      is it true,esatrader belongs to fucker james phang .what i know the money is direct TT to FXDD
      and get aproval direct FXDD.So what comments the CEo Mr andy low.thxs

  244. hot mail says:

    yes , they are a lots of business in the world , we must forget about fast return scheme , all cheat people money .

    At the mean time , We still need our hard earn money from James Phang , Please also do remember , The projects of James Phang is not ” Failed ” … Just not such projects at all , James Phang just collect all the members money and shut down emmax/se. He claimed that the projects was failed , so every body can forgive him . i am going to explain to all the member that , No such projects at all.
    We need our money back , James Phang and his gang should go to Jail.

  245. Anti-SE says:

    Yellow Submarine ,
    Maybe you are right .Weshould forgive Dr.Andy L.Y.Low for talk big , act dump & keep giving empty promises to people.
    He must have study too much untill got mental problem . His whole mind is just thinking to con people .

  246. hot mail says:

    yes , they are a lots of business in the world , we must forget about fast return scheme , all cheat people money .

    At the mean time , We still need our hard earn money from James Phang , Please also do remember , The projects of James Phang is not ” Failed ” … Just not such projects at all , James Phang just collect all the members money and shut down emmax/se. He claimed that the projects was failed , so every body can forgive him . i am going to explain to all the member that , No such projects at all.
    We need our money back , James Phang and his gang should go to Jail

  247. Yellow Submarine says:

    I think the wise and educated should not respond to posts of hatred and vile attacks as I believe Dr Andy has chosen to do henceforth.Brothers and Sisters,you may have lost money or whatever in schemes you invested in but the yesterday is dead and gone forever but you still have the now and the future…maybe it is time to bury the past…go out,start a business or something and recover your losses and show the James Phangs of this world that there are ways to esrn an honest living and live in peace and contentment unlike them….turn your negative thoughts and feelings into positive energy….turn to positive people like Bob Proctor etc…the worldwide web is full of free flowing information if you turn to the right direction…this blog has outlived it’s purpose…forgiveness and forgetfulness is the way forward
    God bless

  248. polis002 says:

    Ding Dong!!! Ding Dong!!! Ding Dong!!!
    Looking for DR..
    DR. DR… Where r u?

  249. Daniel says:

    To all SE Members ,
    Anyone looking for James Phang & Jackie Hoo may go ESA Trader . Stupid James Phang using ESA Trader to scam people’s money . He is still hiding in ESA Trader.Idiot Dr. Andy L. Y. Low often having meeting with James Phang in ESA Trader office.

  250. Anti-SE says:

    Warning !!
    Another James Phang’s scam compnay in singapore & Malaysia: ESA Trader
    Those who already put in money at ESA Trader , please withdraw you money immediately before you loss all your money.
    Sunshine Empire’s scammer : Terry Tan is Account Advisor in ESA Trader.
    Withdraw your money immediately.

  251. JJ says:

    Dennis Loh ,
    Confirmed. ESA Trader is another James Phang’s scam company.Tell all your friends and members don’t join ESA Trader.For sure money goes in but can not withdraw.

  252. JJ says:

    Lucky I and my friend did not put in money at ESA Trader(James Phang’s forex company ). Stay away with anthing company related to scammer JAMES PHANG.Please keep me updates about scam company :ESA Trader . I’ll share it with my friends.
    Thanks.

  253. cnythia says:

    if ESA is real, why they cliam they hv office in the gardens, mid valley n and cyber but they never let any member go to office? because the office they register with another company name call “elitesoft” why u buy esa starter kit but pay to elitesoft? why they dun let u pay to ESA directly?
    why esa business so good but dun dare to hv own REAL office and let member go there??? why run business like underground rat maze, why dun do real business the real way under bright sunlight? coz they cannot see light!!! see light die!!!

    think properly ppl, why a “good” business like this hv no real office in the whole world? but use another name to register for a little working space? coz they can run away anytime, n u have nothing solid to do anything!

    the so called DR. CEO til now after so many ppl tell him TERRY TAN is big time scammer, and he still act dump still think he use Terry tan as ACCOUNT ADVISOR have no probem!!! study too much until normal human logic also dun have liao.come out do business dunno anything bout the market. Or Never do research come out do business ah???
    this kind of business u dare to do? he think ppl see him DR will believe everything he say liao, including when he act dump

    u still want this DR.CEO handle ur money???

  254. Dear all,

    I have an obligation to rectify whatever wrong information about ESA Trader. It seems like the people here are not psychological stable and kept on launching a personal attack. If anyone wishes to enquire and give constructive feedback, please email me at [email protected] I shall try to answer all your doubts. Thank you.

    Best regards,
    Dr. Andy

  255. Anti-SE says:

    To Dr.Andy Cock,
    I guess there were no business for ESA Trader that’s why Dr.Andy L.Y.Low try to promote himself and his company here.
    Stupid Dr.Andy L.Y.Low don’t anything about Sunshine Empire and came in here for what ?

    • Pollis002 says:

      Yes!!!!!!!!!Yes!!!!!!!Yes!!!!!!!
      I Support u!!! YIPPI!!!!!!

      Stupid Dr.Andy L.Y.Low don’t anything about Sunshine Empire and came in here for what ??!!

  256. Anti JP says:

    Yes . this blog are 100 % to tell people not believe at mother fuc-ker james phang.
    We are not welcome below people to promote their prodcut here.

    Dr.Andy L.Y..LOw,

  257. junyang02 says:

    Hi Andy, would you provide me your email address so that we can keep in updates details.? =) cheers.

  258. Anti-SE says:

    Dr.Andy L.Y..LOw,
    You have been telling lie to us . You claimed that you have no idea about Sunshine Empire at all .
    Then why you are in this blog at the first place ?
    This blog is purely for Sunshine Empire issues and updates .
    Is it true about Toh’s statement.You are really good at ACTING DUMP.
    You are Dr.Acting Dump.

  259. Toh says:

    To all trader ,
    Be very careful .
    1) 40% of ESA member are from Sunshine Empire(James Phang) & Grand Elitia .
    2) Dr. Andy L. Y. Low do not allow people to tell the truth about ESA Trader .
    3) Dr. Andy L. Y. Low had recruited scammer Terry Tan (Sunshine Empire’s scammer) as his Account Advisor.
    4) ESA Trader have very nice website but do not have real office in Asia .
    5) ESA Trader using MLM method but without having the MLM lisence from goverment.
    6) The boss behind ESA Trader very high possiblility is James Phang.
    7) FXDD is well known as not reliable broker .
    8) CEO of ESA Trader (Dr.Andy ) like to talk big , showing off & acting dump.James Phang’s talking style .
    9) Dr.Andy afraid to put thier management name in their website.Try to hide it from members.
    10) Few of the trader had complaint they loss a lot of money & can not withdraw their money .
    11) 18% of ESA Trader member already left ESA Trader due to Dr.Andy never kept his word . Empty promises.
    12) ESA Trader: When earning ,Dr.Andy takes all the profit.when loss of money ,member bare all the losses.(Exactly same as Sunshine Empire’s scam)

  260. Toh says:

    Dr. Andy L. Y. Low,
    1)Why you so scare to talk about the fact of your partner : Terry Tan ?
    2) Why 40% of your mangament/member is from Sunshine Empire ?
    3) Why you always follow James Phang’s taliking style by acting dump & talk big ?
    4) Why you stop people who trying to tell the truth about ESA Trader ?
    5) Why you so scare people to know the truth about ESA Trader ?

  261. smallkid says:

    Toh,
    i think you are too careless.. keep on let people scam you. you need to be more smart in future. nothing is free. win or lose is bcoz of ur decission making.

  262. edmundfong says:

    Toh,

    I think we are more interested to know about you. Not Terry Tan, as i see ESA TRADER doing nothing wrong by trading forex with FXDD using EA. My friend is a 7 years forex trader with FXCM and FXDD.

    I think you must be losing too much money to James Phang til cant think logically.

    Poor you.

  263. $ucker says:

    hi all….

    time will tell alot of things…
    Some MLM expert had predicted GRI will be done deal by end of this year or early this year….

    And continue by ESATRADER. Don get it wrong… ESATRADER and ESA Trader is totally different company… pls received the $ucker punch the great Dr. Andy L. Y.Low !

    If you are dare enuff then publish your full name and let us check ur background !? I bet you won’t dare and reply that why u need to do that rite?

    So i would said pls stop all this a$$hole !
    Because this is the common tactics you all use….
    Pls reply ppl with fact and real paper… don talk rubbish any more…

  264. David,Sg says:

    40% of the ESA Trader members are from Sunshine Empire.No wonder i met so many of them at the forex meetng .
    Sure ESA Trader should have something to do with James Phang.
    James Phang still continue his scam by using ESA Trader to collect money from member ? I thought he already in jail.

  265. Tony says:

    Dr. Andy L. Y. Low,
    Wow . Such a high profile for you. Seems that you are trying to show off over here .
    Since you are so smart ,why when ever talking about your partner Terry Tan(Sunshine Empire’s Scammer),you don’t know anything about him .
    1) Was it James Phang who teach you to act dump ?
    2) Why 40% of your management & member are all Sunshine Empire’s member ?
    3) What kind of deal you had with James Phang ?
    4) Why you send Terry Tan to meet up with Ken Lee(James Phang’s represantative) ? What was the discussion about ?
    5) When Sunshine Empire’s member can to take back our re-fund ?

    • Dear Tony,

      I am not showing off, it is just that you are feeling doubtful on my qualifications.

      1. I do not know who James Phang is.
      2. Are you sure 40% of my management and members are from SE? Please note that we do not do any background search on whoever joining us since we cannot give our own judgement based on what we perceive.
      3. I am speechless but if you really have any issue with him personally, please do not pull everyone to relate with him.
      4. As I said many times and you are repeating your questions here. We do not send anyone to meet anyone. This is a free market, I do not judge people like what you did here.
      5. No comments since I have no knowledge and information on it. I suggest you should ask the relevant authority.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  266. Tony says:

    To Dr. Andy L. Y. Low (CEO of ESA Trader),
    Dr.Andy starting to act dump . Way to go man !!

    I Think Dr.Andy L.Y.Low is too qualify to win the Best Actor in Grammy Awards.

    Surely your title DR was given by yourself.

    Scammer.

    Haha .

    • Dear Mr. Tony,

      I really wish you could just cool yourself down since you are launching a personal attacks against me.

      I graduated from the University of Birmingham, United Kingdom with 1st Class Honours in Electronics and Communications Engineering. I obtained my Ph.D. after getting an Asia PhD Scholarship in UK as well. I published more than 30 over international refereed journal papers (excluding conference papers) after 11 years of research and development. I was attached to British Telecom (BT) since 2005. I worked on various algorithms in signal predictions when I was with BT together with Intel, USA, Nokia and Nokia-Siemens Networks.

      Please do not try to tarnish my credential just merely because of whatever reasons you may have. I hope you understand what you are writting here.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  267. Toh says:

    Andy,
    Now you pretended you don’t any thing about Terry Tan ? You are very smart :to act as you don’t anything.
    That is exactly the way of James Phang(Sunshne Empire’s scam) .Talk big all the time when ask to tell the truth,start acting dump.Scammer’s way.
    How could you be CEO of ESA Trader if you don’t know so many things(act dump).Maybe you are CEO of Acting Dump.
    Actually you know well about Terry Tan’s scam history ,you just afraid to tell your members .Trying to hide the truth.
    Your partnet,Terry Tan(012-4882284) conned many people to join scam company Sunshine Empire ,Emmax & Grand Elitia.He run away with a lot of member’s money.
    All of Terry Tan’s member got suffer badly and he driving the BMW. Scammer really earn good.
    .
    Your title Dr. Andy L. Y. Low ?
    I would say you are Dr.Acting Dump .Dr.Hiding The Truth.
    .
    No one would respect you anymore.
    .
    I suggest you to go to hell ,you liar.

    • Dear Mr. Toh,

      I suggest you to cool down. You are getting too personal here. We are discussing the topics here. You are launching a personal attack for God knows what reason.

      As I said, I have no knowledge about Mr. Terry Tan’s past history. I know what I am talking about here. I do no wish to know about anyone’s past history. As long as what we are doing here is the right thing. I am not protecting anyone here as well. Please be understand.

      If you have any personal issues against someone, I would suggest you not to drag everyone in. I will treat your comments as getting too excited over an individual.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

      • paul says:

        “I have no knowledge about Mr. Terry Tan’s past history. I know what I am talking about here. I do no wish to know about anyone’s past history. As long as what we are doing here is the right thing. I am not protecting anyone here as well. Please be understand.”

        As such a corporate and experience guy, I am very curious why you say that you do not know who Terry Tan was?

  268. YC. says:

    My opinion – it is very little chance that FXDD will con you as they are quite a well known Forex broker.

    As for ESA Trader, SaaS is quite a lucrative business model no matter traders win or loose. The key is sustainability! In order to sustain their business, the only choice is to make money for their clients. And this is not an easy job especially the size of the fund become bigger and everybody placing the same trades. FXDD is a broker and size does matter to them. They are acting as a middle platform and trade against their clients. If the EA perform well, they have plenty of tricks to apply. One of them is to increase the spread and re-quote. This is the problem with FAPTurbo when it become mass marketed. That’s why FAPTurbo come out with Evolution version that trade only with Dukascopy (ECN, not broker). And the original version become fully flexible with many adjustable variables so that traders can adjust to perform better than their default settings.

    As for marketer of ESA Trader, the commission is depend on the sustainability issue.

    Just my opinion…

  269. Toh says:

    Andy,
    Now you pretended you don’t any thing about Terry Tan ? You are very smart :to act as you don’t anything.
    That is exactly the way of James Phang(Sunshne Empire’s scam) .Talk big all the time when ask to tell the truth,start acting dump.Scammer’s way.
    How could you be CEO of ESA Trader if you don’t know so many things(act dump).Maybe you are CEO of Acting Dump.
    Actually you know Terry Tan’s scam history ,you just afraid to tell your members .Trying to hide the truth.
    Your partnet,Terry Tan(012-4882284) conned many people to join scam company Sunshine Empire ,Emmax & Grand Elitia.He run away with a lot of member’s money.
    All of Terry Tan’s member got suffer badly and he driving the BMW. Scammer really earn good.
    .
    Your title Dr. Andy L. Y. Low ?
    I would say you are Dr.Acting Dump .Dr.Hiding The Truth.
    .
    No one would respect you anymore.
    .
    I suggest you to go to hell ,you liar.

  270. new bid says:

    Hong Kong Head office:http://www.google.com/search?q=IFC+Unit+3316%2C+33%2FF%2C+One+International+Finance+Centre%2C+1+Harbour+View+Street%2C+Central%2C+Hong+Kong&sourceid=ie7&rls=com.microsoft:en-us:I

    China office:http://www.google.com/search?q=Office+1206+12%2FF+Shui+On+Plaza+333+Huai+Hai+Zhong+Road%2C+Lu+Wan+District+Shanghai+%28zip+code%3A+200021%29+P.R.China&sourceid=ie7&rls=com.microsoft:en-us:I

    Singapore office:http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rls=com.microsoft%3Aen-us%3AIE-SearchBox&q=80+Raffles+Place%2C+Level+36%2C+UOB+Plaza+1+Singapore+048624&btnG=Search

    Thailand office:
    http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rls=com.microsoft%3Aen-us%3AIE-SearchBox&rlz=1I7RNTN_en&q=27%2FFQ+House+Lumpini+Tower+1+South+Sathorn+Road%2C+Tungmahamek+Sathorn%2C+Bangkok+10120+Thailand+&btnG=Search

  271. new bid says:

    Please visit the link below:
    香港总公司:http://www.google.com/search?q=IFC+Unit+3316%2C+33%2FF%2C+One+International+Finance+Centre%2C+1+Harbour+View+Street%2C+Central%2C+Hong+Kong&sourceid=ie7&rls=com.microsoft:en-us

    中国:http://www.google.com/search?q=Office+1206+12%2FF+Shui+On+Plaza+333+Huai+Hai+Zhong+Road%2C+Lu+Wan+District+Shanghai+%28zip+code%3A+200021%29+P.R.China&sourceid=ie7&rls=com.microsoft:en-us

    新加坡:http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rls=com.microsoft%3Aen-us%3AIE-SearchBox&q=80+Raffles+Place%2C+Level+36%2C+UOB+Plaza+1+Singapore+048624&btnG=Search

    泰国:http://www.google.com/search?hl= … ailand+&btnG=Search

  272. Cynthia says:

    For those who trades with ESA TRADER, Please check this link — http://www.forexpeacearmy.com/public/review/www.fxdd.com

    It makes me wonder why they choose such a bad reputation broker, and why? because they are not regulated by any body as well.

    I have friends in Hong Kong, and I’ve get my friends to check out their so called “incorperated” in Hong Kong office (the one stated on the website), and it turns out that the office is non-exist. It is a virtual office. For those who don’t know what is virtual office, go search it. it means they “rent” a “company address” just for the put the company name there, but in actual, they do not have office. it’s something like Imaginary Office. After i hear that, i check all the other so called address of other office in china, singapre, and thailand, ALL ALSO VIRTUAL OFFICE!! which means, this “company” have NO office AT ALL! they are all just empty shell!

    go search their address, you will see a lot of comapany, also using the exactly same address,
    because why, they also rent the same address!

    So it means that if you got a problem, suddenly they disappear, and you thought u still can find them in the office, and you will end up no place to go to, BECAUSE IT NEVER EXIST.

    AND that is not the worst yet, the so called “FINANCIAL Broker” the NZ Finance, ALSO VIRTUAL OFFICE, How in the hell a real financial broker can function even without a proper office???

    So think again if you think you want to invest in this company

    This is so James Phang style. disappear with no sign left for you to search!
    Can anyone explain to me, if their system is so good, why would they want to employ so many SE and emmax ppl to help them run this business??

    if you really interested in Forex, better find a regulated broker to trade with,
    No regulated broker have a lot of problem, simply let ppl use their system, and have no control on them, these type broker very dangerous. they can cut you off without give u good reason, and they not afraid to do that coz they are not binded by regulation!

    • Dear Cynthia,

      Regarding FXDD, I think I have explained it many times, probably you did not have time to read the previous posts. I repost it here

      “NFA registration does not mean the clients are safeguarded in any case. If we think it is only regulated FOREX broker may safeguard your capital, then it is not right. FXDD began as a subsidiary of Tradition North America within the Tradition Group of companies. (http://www.traditiongroup.com/uk/home3.asp). FXDD’s management, operation, compliance, customer relations and its financial policies and procedures were structured to meet the Tradition Group’s oversight and those policies and procedures remain firmly in place.

      In my opinion, part of the reasons why their membership is still pending is due to the recent NFA announcement that it has put an end to Forex Trading priviledges in the USA such as 1) stop/loss 2) hedging and 3) closing orders which some believe helps induce profitability.”

      Due to limited space, I shall post my reply to your comments in the next reply.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

    • Dear Cynthia,

      For your information, we are renting Regus serviced office. You may go to http://www.regus.com/ instead of google search. We are using their service since most of the corporates are using them (eg. Intel, BT, Nokia etc.). We believe in their reliable services.

      You have to understand, we are the software as a service (SaaS) provider. We do not need a huge corporate office. Our business is very transparent as it is based on pay per use basis. Anyone can stop their auto trading at any time and there will be no more charge. Perhaps it is new to the market on this concept.

      Your comments let me think of Lehman Brothers, Barings Bank etc., they have huge presence and offices worldwide, but what is happening to them now.

      Regarding NZ Financial, it is an offshore finance company, it is normal for offshore finance company to use serviced office since usually offshore finance companies only serve high net worth clients with strict confidentiality. They do not do retail businesses. This is the pre-requisite for that. We have been doing a lot of negotiation with NZ Financial to be associated with ESA Trader. If anyone has any doubts in their services, please let us know.

      Just to clarify your statement, we DO NOT employ SE and emmax (though I personally do not know what companies are they) people to do marketing, our model is based on rebates. Anyone can do it.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  273. Toh says:

    Andy L. Y. Low ,
    1)Please clarify who is Terry Tan ?
    2) Is this Terry Tan(012-4882284) who were Sunshine Empire scammer & Grand Elitia scammer ?
    3) What is the relationhip between you,Terry Tan & Kee Lee(SE & Grand Elitia Scammer) ?
    Please explain to us without lie .
    Tell us the truth here.
    Explain now.

    • Dear Toh,

      1. I am not sure your Terry Tan here but as far as I know Terry T. T. Tan is one of our Account Advisors.

      2. I have no idea of his past history.

      3. As I said, Terry TT Tan is one of our Account Advisors, I have no idea who is this Kee Lee.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  274. Toh says:

    Andy L. Y. Low ,
    1)Please explain who is Terry Tan ?
    2) Is this Terry Tan(012-4882284) who joined Sunshine Empire & grand Elitia scam company ?
    3) What is the relationhip between Terry Tan & Kee Lee(SE & Grand Elitia Scammer) ?
    Please explain to us without lie .
    Tell us the truth here.

  275. Shame JP says:

    I think James Phang live in this world is meaningless , always scoled by members . i never see a man like him .

  276. Dr. Andy L. Y. Low says:

    To all Trader,
    I need to clearify .I knew Terry Tan for many years and he is a very honest person. Terry Tan have nothing to do with Sunshine Empire ,Emmax,Grand Elitia & eforexcity,fxautobots & gainsfx.
    As i understand ,when you invest your money in fxautobots/gainsfx ,they not really put in your money in forex broker .They take your money to do somethnig else but not reallly in forex.That is why they don’t allow you to withdraw your investment for 1 year.
    In fact,eforexcity/gainsfx/fxautobots was converted from Sunshine Empire & Grand Elitia ,they had a very bad scam history which run away with all a lot of member’s hard earn money.
    Their management people: James Phang,Jackie Hoo & Ken Lee were blacklisted scammer in Singapore & Malaysia who we have no relationship with him at all .
    Best regards,
    Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

    • Hi there,

      I need to clarify that I, DO NOT post the above comments. Someone is using my name to post the above comments. This is truly absurd and reflect his/her wisdom.

      Perhaps the blog’s owner should have some sort of control mechanism here.

      Truly disappointed,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  277. Dr. Andy L. Y. Low says:

    I need to clearify .I knew Terry Tan for many years and he is a very honest person. Terry Tan have nothing to do with Sunshine Empire ,Emmax,Grand Elitia & eforexcity,fxautobots & gainsfx.
    As i understand ,when you invest your money in fxautobots/gainsfx ,they not really put in your money in forex broker .They take your money to do somethnig else but not reallly in forex.That is why they don’t allow you to withdraw your investment for 1 year.
    In fact,eforexcity/gainsfx/fxautobots was converted from Sunshine Empire & Grand Elitia ,they had a very bad scam history which run away with all a lot of member’s hard earn money.
    Their management people: James Phang,Jackie Hoo & Ken Lee already blacklisted scammer in Singapore & Malaysia who we have no relationship with him at all .
    Best regards,
    Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  278. Penny says:

    I joined ESA Trader under Terry Tan. He said ESA Trader’s forex sure win .After i invested ,within 2 months i loss about RM8,000. Terry Tan refused to answer my call . I would tell my friend about ESA Trader’s scam .

  279. Daniel says:

    If anyone want to find James Phang ,Ken Lee & Terry Tan , you may go to Grand Elitia & ESA Trader to look for them . These scammer are now hiding at ESA Trader.

  280. Hate Emmax says:

    Yes , James Phang(彭桦) mother fuc-ker, face looked like a pig , just knew con member money and watch X dvd , hiding like a rat at home .Shameful …. Dont believe this guys , his behavior and image totally out … not humen being ,Animal. Ants also better them him , Stupid pig 彭桦.

  281. SAD Malaysia says:

    But the main purpose for us at here is , we need the return money form fuc-ker james phang , he con us a lots ,

  282. Daniel says:

    Sad,
    Terry Tan currently hiding in ESA Trader keep on con and scam people’s money.Tell all SE & Grand Elitia member to find him at ESA Trader.Don’t let him run away with our money.His H/P:012-4882284.

  283. Corns says:

    Anybody knows Jarrod Luo?

    He’s involved in Sunshine Empire n now dealin with online gamble. He’s now in SDP as well.

    http://notmysdp.blogspot.com/2009/10/whos-jarrod-luo.html

    • hengzzz says:

      u must be notmysdp from EDWM.

      anyway, u may kena sue left right centre if the source is unreliable!!!!!!!!!

      in short, either u boomz or he boomz!!! LOLX

  284. Sad says:

    Terry Tan .The one who drive a white BMW ? Terry was Sunshine Empire & Grand Elitia scammer.He have run away a lot of his member’s money . His name already blacklisted in Singapore & Malaysia. Where is he now ? We still looking for him .

  285. Toh says:

    Currently another scam company : ESA Trader. So many scam in the market. Have to be very careful.

  286. SAD Malaysia says:

    All this investment just cheat people like emmax/sunshine empire

  287. Bernard Leo says:

    Terry Tan also did told us that Gainsfx can guaranty member/customer zero loss and they have High Frequency Trading Platform.Where else for ESA Trader,members/customer will bare all the losses.ESA Trader not really concern about their member’s money.

  288. Bernard Leo says:

    Are Gainsfx and ESA Trader the same forex company ? Terry Tan & Ken Lee just approuched me to invest USD10,000 in Gainsfx. Maybe Terry Tan is right,inside ESA Trader got a lot of hidden problem.Very messy.

  289. low says:

    In God I trust, everyone is a suspect….
    So trust no one…

    By the way, there is a lot of website that can trade FX…go for the more recognise one… in singapore like iOCBC, POEMs etc….or fxcm website – give your free US$25 to try to trade before you decide to go on real one…

    In Singapore, our govt will not help us especially CASE…, you need to help yourself…even time share scam is also happening like what Sunshire Empire, also amway etc…still surviving in singapore..

    • smallkid says:

      you are right… dont just follow what people say.. you your own must understand all the risk as you are the only one who will pay for the risk…

  290. Terry's downline says:

    Comment by Dr. Andy L. Y. Low
    2009-10-06 11:18:18
    ———————————–

    Dear Andy,
    I am surprised you are considering to enter the trading competition. As far as i know, the robot is not meant for sale but rent. If you join the competition, you have to surrender the robot. If that is the case, please sell me the robot, thanks.

  291. FC says:

    Please provide me more detial about ESA Trader .My uncle already put in money . If ESA Trader is illegal & no lesen ,i will ask my uncle to withdraw all his money .

    • Dear FC,

      SaaS providers do not require licenses to operate. As I mentioned before, ESA Trader DOES NOT collect funds and DOES NOT authorise any parties to collect funds as well. I hope you are not be giving out false alarm without finding more about us.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  292. Penny says:

    I and my friend will withdraw all our money for ESA Trader immediately. Not secure & no license forex compnay .

    • Dear Penny,

      I personally welcome you to withdraw. Just to correct your statement. ESA Trader is not…I repeat…IS NOT a FOREX company. We are not a broker as well. We are a SaaS provider. What is SaaS? SaaS stands for Software as a Service. Our model is based on pay per use. We are providing a platform to assist traders in FOREX. I hope Anyone and any parties are welcome to stop using our software at anytime. Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  293. bystander says:

    Hmm.. ESA Trader minimum startout account is USD3000. sounds fishy to me already. Many online online forex trading coms starts from USD300-500.

  294. Daniel says:

    Terry Tan was Sunshine Empire & Grand Elitia member. He used to work under James Phang .Terry Tan caused a lot of member loss money and run away.A lo of Sunshine ember still searching for him .He and Ken Lee are good friend.Currently Ken Lee still helping James Phang to scam more people.ESA Trader is another James Phang’s scam.

  295. Victim says:

    STAY AWAY! Beware scam by James Phang:
    1) eForexCity (Forex)
    2) GainsFX (Forex)
    3) Grand Royale International(GRI)
    4) fxautobots.com (Forex)
    5) ESA Trader(Forex)

  296. CCY says:

    ESA Trader using MLM sheme but not need lisence ? Very risky company.
    Same as James Phang’s style .Everything is legal but no lisence . End up,shut down by gavorment .

  297. CCY says:

    ESA Trader using MLM sheme but not need lisence ? Very risking company.
    James Phang’s style .Everything is legal but no lisence . End up,shuit down by gavorment .

  298. SAD Malaysia says:

    STAY AWAY! Beware scam by mother fuc-ker James Phang:
    1) eForexCity (Forex)
    2) GainsFX (Forex)
    3) Grand Royale International(GRI)
    4) fxautobots.com (Forex)

  299. CCY says:

    So ESA Trader is an illegal forex compmay without lisence .Not lisence can be close down any time .

    • Dear CCY,

      I hope my explanation to Toh helps you understand it. We are very serious in our business, if you think I am here for short term businesses then I am sorry to let you down. I will never ever risk my credential for this.

      Incorporation in Hong Kong is partly due to their friendly business environment. Some even ask us to incorporate in other offshore places but I am strongly against it since I believe that if our intention is good, then everyone will understand it.

      One point I MUST let everyone knows that we DO NOT and ARE NOT allowed to collect any funds or deposit taking. We are purely providing a platform services such as indicators and EA. If any parties that claim have partnership or affiliate with us, please let us know.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  300. Toh says:

    If ESA Trder uisng 10-level deep MLM scheme without having MLM license in consider illegal compnay.

  301. Toh says:

    Does ESA Trader have any MLM license in Malaysia ?

    • Dear Mr. Toh,

      We do not have any MLM license in Malaysia and we do not need it since the company is incorporated in Hong Kong. So far, it is the market which perceives us as MLM company. I was made understood that in Malaysia, any rebates which goes beyond 5 levels require license and the procedures can be very messy.

      To be frank with you, our intention to grow the company is beyond Malaysia market. We are here based on sincere heart since the founders are all Malaysian. All this while, we do not even want to explain much about the rebates because all our students earn more from their own FOREX accounts.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  302. YC. says:

    Dear Dr Andy,

    I’m the internet marketer from Malaysia, and have successfully sold many EAs like FapTurbo and Forex Megadroid.

    I’ve just met up with a guy in Penang about ESA Trader. They approached me to sell it through my existing contacts. I’m very suspicious about ESA based on two simple logical reasons:

    1. Website – no management info, only a very general statement
    2. 10-level deep MLM scheme – if the system is good, why need to run it through such a deep level MLM scheme?

    Appreciate your valuable input.

    Besides, I would suggest ESA Trader to submit your EA to compete with the other EAs in the world through Forex Robot World Cup (by FXCM & Boston Tech) and it’s a good branding building for ESA Trader.

    Thanks & regards.

    • Dear YC,

      Really glad to read your comments. At least it shows that there are wise men reading this blog. :)

      In fact, FabTurbo is one the best EA that I come across. Allow me to rectify your statement, we DO NOT sell out EA. The guy who told you to sell to your contacts is not technically right. Our business model is based on traded lot commissions and also very minimum amount of basic training.

      1. Regarding the website, we are not focusing on our management staff but more focus on what services that we could offer. I understand that some companies tend to put their management information in order to attract investor to invest in their companies. We are NOT. In addition, there are many parties out there trying to headhunt our staff. We are trying to protect our own interest. Have you ever seen Intel, BT, Nokia publish their key people onto their website? I think not even Fabturbo doing that…well I may be wrong

      Shall reply your following question in subsequent comments due to limited space.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

    • Dear YC,

      I am glad to read your comments. At least it shows that there are wise men reading the blog. I have to make some minor corrections to your statement. We do not sell our EA. Our business model is based on traded lot commission. In fact, you are right, FapTurbo is one of the good EA that I come across. I will encourage people to try it if possible.

      1. We appreciate your input on the management information. The main intention is to protect our management staff since I was made understanding that there are people trying to headhunt our key people. This is the corporate culture where we are trying to protect our own interest here. Some small companies tend to put their management information on their website to attract potential investors or venture capitalists to invest in their companies. But this is not our company direction. We are very confident on our business direction.

      I shall answer to your subsequent comment in the next due to limited space. Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

    • Dear YC,

      Sorry as I duplicate my reply above due to the lagging of the blog and I thought it was not included. Apologies for that.

      2. MLM? We just purely give out rebates from part of the commissions. Not sure whether you are aware that even unit trust agents are enjoying 4 to 5 tiers commissions rebate but why we do not classify them as MLM? Are you suggesting that we should change this marketing strategy? Do you have any better idea then I am willing to listen.

      Participation in competition is really good for publicity. In big hedge funds like the one managed by George Soros, they have something called a BLACK BOX for capital market which is highly secured. They do not go for competition, right?

      I have been experiencing various competitions in R&D activities up to even wining the Frost & Sullivan R&D Awards for British Telecom (BT) in 2008 but many of such competitions are not really meeting the business needs.

      Your suggestion is very good indeed. I might look into the compeition participation durng my management meeting.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  303. YC. says:

    Dear Dr Andy,

    I’m the internet marketer from Malaysia, and have successfully sold many EAs like FapTurbo and Forex Megadroid.

    I’ve just met up with a guy in Penang about ESA Trader. They approached me to sell it through my existing contacts. I’m very suspicious about ESA based on two simple logical reasons:

    1. Website – no management info, only a very general statement at http://esatrader.com/our-people/
    2. 10-level deep MLM scheme – if the system is good, why need to run it through such a deep level MLM scheme?

    Appreciate your valuable input.

    Besides, I would suggest ESA Trader to submit your EA to compete with the other EAs in the world through
    http://www.forex-robot-world-cup.com
    and it’s a good branding building for ESA Trader.

    Thanks & regards.

  304. Daniel says:

    Andy ,
    You don’t know who is James Phang ? Then why you send Terry Tan to represent you to meet up with Ken Lee(Sunshine Empire Scammer) ? Please explain .
    Something must be very wrong in ESA Trader.Don’t lie to us anymore.

    • Dear Daniel,

      I have been in the academia for the past 11 years. I do not know who Jame Phang is. As I mentioned, who are we to judge Ken Lee? I believe in next life, we have to treat others with good intention. When it comes to our judgement day (death), then at least we leave a goodwill behind. Again I am not asking you to believe me but at least please use your own wisdom before you draw any conclusions.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  305. Dear all,

    There are many of my friends asking me not to bother in replying the comments in this blog as there are from unknown sources and baseless. To me, I view that it is my responsibility to explain and bring the rightful. I really wish to see that I could bring those to the right path. At least do not disseminate wrong information in the net and abuse the freedom of thoughts in blogs.

    Thank you.

    Best regards,
    Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

    • YC. says:

      Dear Dr. Andy,

      I’m the internet marketer from Malaysia, and have successfully sold many EAs like FapTurbo and Forex Megadroid.

      I’ve just met up with a guy in Penang about ESA Trader. They approached me to sell it through my existing contacts. I’m very suspicious about ESA based on two simple logical reasons:

      1. Website – no management info, only a very general statement at http://esatrader.com/our-people/
      2. 10-level deep MLM scheme – if the system is good, why need to run it through such a deep level MLM scheme?

      Appreciate your valuable input.

      Besides, I would suggest ESA Trader to submit your EA to compete with the other EAs in the world through
      http://www.forex-robot-world-cup.com
      and it’s a good branding building for ESA Trader.

      Thanks & regards.

  306. YC says:

    Dear Dr. Andy,

    I’m the internet marketer from Malaysia, and have successfully sold many EAs like FapTurbo and Forex Megadroid.

    I’ve just met up with a guy in Penang about ESA Trader. They approached me to sell it through my existing contacts. I’m very suspicious about ESA based on two simple logical reasons:

    1. Website – no management info, only a very general statement at http://esatrader.com/our-people/
    2. 10-level deep MLM scheme – if the system is good, why need to run it through such a deep level MLM scheme?

    Appreciate your valuable input.

    Besides, I would suggest ESA Trader to submit your EA to compete with the other EAs in the world through
    http://www.forex-robot-world-cup.com
    and it’s a good branding building for ESA Trader.

    Thanks & regards.

  307. YC. says:

    Dear Andy,

    I’m the internet marketer from Malaysia, and have successfully sold many EAs like FapTurbo and Forex Megadroid.

    I’ve just met up with a guy in Penang about ESA Trader. They approached me to sell it through my existing contacts. I’m very suspicious about ESA based on two simple logical reasons:

    1. Website – no management info, only a very general statement at http://esatrader.com/our-people/
    2. 10-level deep MLM scheme – if the system is good, why need to run it through such a deep level MLM scheme?

    Appreciate your valuable input.

    Besides, I would suggest ESA Trader to submit your EA to compete with the other EAs in the world through
    http://www.forex-robot-world-cup.com
    and it’s a good branding building for ESA Trader.

    Thanks & regards.

  308. Daniel says:

    Andy ,
    Anything related to James Phang is complicated . Only cause people loss money .Do you know Terry Tan often meet up and have some deal with Ken Lee ? Ken Lee is Sunshine Empire’s management.Maybe you should check with Terry Tan about this.

    • Dear Daniel,

      Frankly, I personally do not know who James Phang is until I read this blog and asked my friends around. It is very unfortunate for those who are the victims. I am indeed sorry to hear that. My philosophy is very simple. Whoever wishes to invest and approach us, we have to accept. As long as they follow the guidelines, I will not reject.

      If you think Ken Lee is Sunshine Empire’s management and thus he should be punished by not allowing him to join ESA Trader, then I am afraid you are wrong. To me, as long as the bylaws allow them to do whatever the general public could do, we cannot stop. This is to uphold the professionalism.

      I have been in the academia for the past decade, I think we have to uphold the profesional ethics as long as everything is done properly. Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  309. Connie Ooi says:

    No matter what,i’m going to withdraw my money any way . ESA Trader made me loss USD16000 .Shouldn’t trusted them at the first place .

  310. Connie Ooi says:

    Friday discussion still on,right ? This is very serious.I don’t know ESA Trader have such bad history . They covered it up.We must take back our money immediately .

    • Dear Connie,

      You are most welcome to take out the money. In fact, we strongly encourage you to do so. But please bear in mind, you must take out the money that you deposited in FXDD because ESA Trader does not collect any funds deposit.

      You have to fill in the funds redemption form by FXDD. Usually it will take 3 business days to transfer your money back to your account.

      We thank you for your support of ESA Trader in the past. Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  311. Ng says:

    ESA Trader got too many problem.What kind of forex company is this ? Sometihng really very wrong to this company.Must leave this company soonest possible.

  312. Ng says:

    KK.Lim,
    We don’t want to join ESA Trader as well . James Phang have a lot of bad history . All of his member loss money .
    If you decide you leave EAs Trader , we will follow you as well .Perhaps we can gather all ESA Trader’s members to have a discussion at Midvalle this Firday .I’ll ask Ken Lee to join us .

    • Dear Ng,

      I would personally advise you to make the withdrawal decision yourself rather than follow anyone. As I mentioned, you know yourself better than anyone else. When we do investment, the decision is very critical since we should not follow others. We may end up to be the blinds led by the blinds.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  313. KK.Lim says:

    I guess I & my friend should pull out from ESA Trader . Anything related with James Phang ,we don’t want to join . He have cheated and scam many people already. In fact , ESA Trader starting lossing invester’s money already.Terry Tan have approuched us to join Gainsfx & Eforexcity .

    • Dear Mr. Lim,

      It is not ethical to disseminate false information. I treat your comments as a hoax. In fact, you and your friends are welcome to stop your auto trading and redeem your funds from FXDD at any time. Nevertheless, it is a sin to simply accuse something which are not true.

      Mr. Terry T. T. Tan is the Account Advisor for ESA Trader, I am not sure the Terry Tan who you mentioned in your comment is the same person. At least be responsible of what you wrote.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  314. Daniel says:

    Seemslike ESA Trader is a very complicated Forex comopany to invest in.I guess scammer James Phang purposely to make this comlicated in order to confuss the investor .

    • Dear Daniel,

      Just to rectify your statement. You DO NOT invest in ESA Trader since we DO NOT collect any deposit. The trade is very simple you open your own account at FXDD, you can either do manual trading using our in-house indicator or use your in-house auto trading expert advisor (EA) to trade. I am not sure why you mention it is complicated. I hope I have answered your doubts. Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low

  315. Wongkc says:

    STAY AWAY! Beware scam:
    1) eForexCity (Forex)
    2) GainsFX (Forex)
    3) Grand Royale International(GRI)
    4) fxautobots.com (Forex)

  316. Shawn says:

    Funny people we have here!! On what basis to deduct that James Phang is behind ESA? If the deduction is due to fact that many JP people are in it, then i guess you all are too naive.

    Imagine JP people join AIA and selling AIA Insurance, does that equates JP having a share in AIA? However, i don’t blame you all from hating JP, as i too lost alot in him. Just don’t link ESA with him unless you know the absolute truth!!

    ESA is truely doing Forex Trading with the open market and all qoutes are live. Means same with Bloomberg!!! You’ve to see to believe!!

    For those who love to listen to people say non-deductive facts, do carry on, because ESA is here to stay and trades Bone Fide.

    Our system show losing and winning trades, we are not afraid that to show losing trades as trading has risk for sure. We educate students to trade manually but only EEA can duplicate high percentage winning trades constantly!!!

    Everytime is see Kishore testimonial of Mona getting 7700% returns in 2mths, i always think how many Mona are there?? I can say even a top trader like Kishore will only produce 1 Mona, because he can’t duplicate!!!

    If he can, he won’t be teaching now, but Kishore technique are good, just that he cant duplicate another Mona in YOU!!!!!

    Analyse what people tell you and make your own wise decision!!!

  317. Wongkc says:

    oh cool man. It’s getting interesting!

  318. smallkid says:

    Dr. Andy… You are the man. I support you.

  319. Dear all,

    I was made understood that there are many people have been the victims of some money making companies in the recent years. No doubts, the offers that those companies made to the people are really very attractive but we have to understand and find out more information the claims. We could not simply accuse some other genuine companies without detail analysis.

    We have to know the way to handle our wealth portfolio. We need to understand our own risk appetite and manage our own wealth wisely instead of just believing in claims from unknown sources.

    If anyone wishes to know more about ESA Trader, I am indeed glad to meet up. Please write to us at [email protected] for such arrangement but it is meant for serious people who are keen to know more. I hope I have made my stand clear here.

    Thank you.

    Best regards,
    Dr. Andy L. Y. Low
    Chief Executive Officer

  320. Daniel says:

    Banned James Phang:
    1) ESA Trader (Forex)
    2) NZ Financial (Forex)
    3) Elite Trader (Forex)
    4) Grand Elitia International(GIR)

  321. FxExpert Trader says:

    You all are right.
    I am an experienced trader.
    Forex funding should bever fund to a company or a broker. We should choose those broker who is regulated like FSA.

    FXDD is old but not regulated, can close shop and take away all investors money.

    NZFinancial not really heard of it, for sure not regulated.

    Funding the money into these 2 brokers are as good as throw money into the ocean.

    Moreover, ESAtrader charge 3pips commisions to trader. They just think of their own advantage.

    BANNED:
    1) ESA Trader (Forex)
    2) NZ Financial (Forex)
    3) Elite Trader (Forex)

    • Dear FXExpert Trader,

      Just some additional points on top of your comments. FSA is the regulatory body in United Kingdom. It does not mean it can regulate all FOREX broker in every countries.

      Likewise, in the USA, it is a total level field than in the UK. Some may refer to the National Future’s Association (NFA) as a guideline but it is not strictly correct since NFA is not a regulatory body. FXDD is currently not a member of NFA. This is because NFA registration does not mean the clients are safeguarded in any case. If we think it is only regulated FOREX broker may safeguard your capital, then it is not right. FXDD began as a subsidiary of Tradition North America within the Tradition Group of companies. (http://www.traditiongroup.com/uk/home3.asp). FXDD’s management, operation, compliance, customer relations and its financial policies and procedures were structured to meet the Tradition Group’s oversight and those policies and procedures remain firmly in place.

      In my opinion, part of the reasons why their membership is still pending is due to the recent NFA announcement that it has put an end to Forex Trading priviledges in the USA such as 1) stop/loss 2) hedging and 3) closing orders which some believe helps induce profitability.

      NZ Financial is just an offshore finance company in New Zealand. All ESA Trader students are aware that they do not handle their investment funds. If one is familiar with offshore finance service, there are thousands of offshore finance companies. Again it depends on individuals.

      ESA Trader makes it very clear to all its student members that its business model is based on lot commission from the usage of its services (eg. in house EA, indicators, financial advice etc). Since you as an experienced trader, you should be aware of other companies which provide similar services by commission basis. Thus,I do hope you will not simply condemn without detail analysis.

      Should any of the readers of this blog have any doubts, you may contact us directly at [email protected]

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low
      Chief Executive Officer

    • Dear FXExpert Trader,

      FSA is the regulatory body in United Kingdom. It does not mean it can regulate all FOREX broker in every countries.

      Likewise, in the USA, it is a total level field than in the UK. Some may refer to the National Future’s Association (NFA) as a guideline but it is not strictly correct since NFA is not a regulatory body. FXDD is currently not a member of NFA. This is because NFA registration does not mean the clients are safeguarded in any case. If we think it is only regulated FOREX broker may safeguard your capital, then it is not right. FXDD began as a subsidiary of Tradition North America within the Tradition Group of companies. (http://www.traditiongroup.com/uk/home3.asp). FXDD’s management, operation, compliance, customer relations and its financial policies and procedures were structured to meet the Tradition Group’s oversight and those policies and procedures remain firmly in place.

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low
      Chief Executive Officer

    • Dear FXExpert Trader,

      In my opinion, part of the reasons why their membership is still pending is due to the recent NFA announcement that it has put an end to Forex Trading priviledges in the USA such as 1) stop/loss 2) hedging and 3) closing orders which some believe helps induce profitability. As an expert FX trader, do you think it is to your advantage or not. Do you want to limit your trading activities?

      NZ Financial is just an offshore finance company in New Zealand. All ESA Trader students are aware that they do not handle their investment funds. If one is familiar with offshore finance service, there are thousands of offshore finance companies. Again it depends on individuals.

      ESA Trader makes it very clear to all its student members that its business model is based on lot commission from the usage of its services (eg. in house EA, indicators, financial advice etc). Since you as an experienced trader, you should be aware of other companies which provide similar services by commission basis. Thus,I do hope you will not simply condemn without detail analysis.

      Should any of the readers of this blog have any doubts, you may contact us directly at [email protected]

      Thank you.

      Best regards,
      Dr. Andy L. Y. Low
      Chief Executive Officer

  322. KL says:

    Where are idiot James Phang & Jackie Hoo hiding ?

  323. SAD Malaysia says:

    SUNSHINE EMPIRE/EMMAX by mother fuc-ker james phang
    This licensed and legal Company has an impressive office at the ground level of KUB building along Jalan Yap K wan Seng, near Menara Public Bank and AmBank Building . They also have a showroom office at the ground level in the next building. 3 or 4 months ago, Singapore ’s Straits Times and The Paper published big news reminding their people to be careful and NOT to believe in them. Hope someone can put up the link or
    > google for it.(As expected, they STOPPED paying back members now and all investors LOST their money).

    Someone below has put a link to the Singapore news. In fact there are more to it. Although Singapore is investigating them, they did not stop their business as the business is legal and so far, no Singaporean have failed to receive their commissions as promised. Thus, the government cannot stop them yet. The news published that the founder, director and group president is someone named James Phang but he is NOT the owner. Isn’t this quite strange ? At the end of the game, James Phang can just disappear from the Company easily and claimed that he was just “employed”. Such trick always happened in scam businesses. Now, the Company has STOPPED paying commissions and interests to members with the excuse that the Singapore government has freezed their bank account while under investigation. Do you think their boss will be so stupid to keep much monies in the bank to be freezed? They are all transfered away. It’s just an excuses not to
    > pay back to members and members are only paid “e-bonus-points” which is cashless. If they wish to
    > convert to cash, they have to recruit new members to pay them cash and the recruiter less out trom the amount. So victims act like Vampires and “forced” to victimise other victims if they wish to get their monies back. And their victims will later transform to vampires and the scam carries on……

  324. KL says:

    Thanks to Ken Lee for inform us about James Phang’s company : ESA Trader . Otherwise we will conned by him . I’ll going to tell everyone don’t join ESA Trader.Scam Forex company.

  325. KL says:

    I got few friends already join ESA Trader. ESA is another James Phang’s company to scam people..I’ll ask them to withdraw ESA Trader soonest possible .

  326. Japan- Inai says:

    Our objective is very clear : Fuc-ker James Phang and his Gangs is setting a scam company . He must go to Jail if not return our money . He always explained that emmax/SE projects was failed. But he just conned money and shut down the company then re-form a new company . ( I want to said that emmax/se projects actually is not fail , NO such projects at all )

  327. Terry Tan says:

    I have checked the website of eforexcity,gainsfx & fxautobots .
    1) No management info .
    2) No telephone .
    3) No office address .
    4) No info about payment methods.
    5) No Forex Platform info .
    6) No license company in Singapore & Malaysia.
    7) Does not looks like a forex’s website at all .
    It is truely a scam company by James Phang & Jackie Hoo.

  328. Daniel says:

    Ken Lee (Represantative of Sunshine Empire,Emmax & Gainsfx ) is trying promote their new scam forex company in Malaysia.
    You may call him about your SE’s refund money . He may explain to you in detail what is going on .
    H/P: 016-4611518
    H/P: 65-90686892

  329. Japan- Inai says:

    He did mistake , He must paid for punishment , We suffered a lots .Go to Jail James Phang,

  330. china says:

    We dont interesting about fuc-ker James Phang projects anymore , The main concern for us are when he can return our money , If he said that this projects was failed ( actually no such projects as well) . He should go to Jail for life for conned people money , like taiwan president.

  331. Wongkc says:

    hi Boy,

    I think you should change your post to

    Dont Joint. Beware scam:
    1) eForexCity (Forex)
    2) GainsFX (Forex)
    3) Grand Royale International(GRI)
    4) fxautobots.com (Forex)

    In fact, i have done my research on ESA Trader, their members are trading with FXDD using auto trade. No doubt FXDD is one of the top forex principal and they have been in the market more than 8 years. Most of the professional forex traders should know about FXDD.

    • malaysia-public says:

      yes, FXDD is well known forex broker (still
      unregulated, NFA pending)

      however, let’s look at ESA’s biz concept:-
      - join membership – RM900
      - gives free EA/robot. trading only eu/usd with
      fix StopLoss 300pips and fix TakeProfit
      30pips. Averaging Down method & Drawdown
      exceeded 30-50% or more, of equity
      (an absurd crazy risk, usually 6 consecutive
      losses trades will wipe out a/c)
      - all whole strategies is to “brain wash”
      newbies to fast& big & high risk so to earn
      fast
      - (this one tricky) all members/students and
      their friends/ppl , everyone, will sign-up
      DIRECTLY under ESA in FXDD Introducer Broker
      program. ESA will then, pay bonueses/rebates
      to members according to the rebate-plan
      and min. member have to trade 20lot! in
      order to qualify.

      Again, the whole concept is to “pushing”
      members to fast earn running their robot
      big account and trade big lot frequently
      (out of risk management(
      Why so? ah… to suck members commission from FXDD’s rebates. The more/frequent members trades the more money ESA will earn from FXDD.
      (no risk at all! risk goes to members’ own money)

      Remember, all members are signed directly
      under ESA in FXDD’s IB program. If something
      goes wrong, ESA simply suck all rebates and
      ‘run away’ with members’ network & their trading volumes.

  332. china says:

    emmax/sunshine empire all cheated money , Just collected all money and said projects failed …. mother fuc-ker , bitch , 干她妈的James Phang , 不得好死.

  333. china says:

    mother fu-cker James phang and Jackie hoo

  334. SE Member says:

    James Phang & Jackie Hoo afraid to tell SE members that the account is actually no money already .Empty account.

  335. SE Member says:

    James Phang & Jackie Hoo trying to drag the court case. B’cos if CAD un-freeze their account ,they have no money to re-fund to members . The account is empty . No money already .All the money have loss to their projects.

  336. Hope Justice Be Brought says:

    Source: http://www.cad.gov.sg/topNav/faq/Sunshine+Empire+Pte+Ltd.htm#name4

    Copied from source:
    Last updated on 28 July 2009
    Q:What is progress of the proceedings in the Subordinate Court?
    A:The matter is fixed for trial from 5 to 30 October 2009 in the Subordinate Court 7. Further updates on the proceedings will be posted on this website.

    My comments:
    This is dragging too long……..
    I simply cannot accept the fact that things are taking ages to come to a conclusion in our society that is seen by many as efficient…..

  337. SE Member says:

    Where is idiot James Phang & Jackie Hoo hiding ?

  338. George says:

    Can not let these scam company to go on like that.
    More people report would be better.
    Singapore Report to : CAD
    Malaysia Report to : Bank Negara

  339. Lee says:

    If we like to report about the scam company eforexcity & gainsfx to local goverment .which department we should report to ? Police dept ?

  340. FC says:

    eforexcity & gainsfx do not have any office in Singapore & Malaysia . Illegal company .

  341. FC says:

    eforexcity & Gainsfx is illegal in Singapore & Malaysia .They don’t have license to collect money from people.That’s why their website very plain.Got no info at all.Be careful .

  342. Daniel says:

    Ken Lee (Represantative of Sunshine Empire ) is trying promote their new forex company in KL .
    You may call him about your SE’s refund money . He may explain to you in detail what is going on .
    H/P: 016-4611518
    H/P: 65-90686892

  343. Jeez says:

    How can Ken be called a representative when SE is not operating anymore?

  344. Daniel Goh says:

    I have gave Ken Lee(Represantative of Sunshine Empire ) a call . He said that James Phang & Jackie Hoo will not have any intention to return any money to all Sunshine Empire member.All the money had loss in all SE’s project.Totally loss .
    Ken Lee.
    H/P: 016-4611518
    H/P: 65-90686892

  345. Boy says:

    Fuck-er James Phang . Return all your scam money.
    Dont Joint.
    1) ESA Trader (Forex)
    2) NZ Financial (Forex)
    3) Grand Royale International(GRI)
    4) Elite Trader (Forex)

  346. Emmax scam says:

    Ya …This two guys all mother fu-cker .Not like a gentlemen , Like a bitch. All the members cannot believe them already.

  347. Emmax scam says:

    Ya …..This two guys all mother fuck-er

  348. Emmax scam says:

    ya … James Phang mother fuck-er ,con members money.

  349. Sad Member says:

    mother fuck-er james pahng and Jackie Hoo

  350. Jack Loo says:

    I don’t understand . Why James Phang and Jackie Hoo still have a lot of money to run their business but no money to return to all SE member who are still suffering ?

  351. hengzzz says:

    Car achiever, Ang Zhao Hui, 21 has been labeled a traitor in Sunshine Empire. Although developments of this incident were unclear, investigation done by forum members of HardwareZone has shown clearly that Ang Zhao Hui had an exchange with the director Jackie Hoo in Facebook. Screenshots of their Facebook profile wall exchange were captured and uploaded. References of Shoe, loyalty and brother were mentioned a few times in their exhange.[4]

    SOURCE :
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunshin…re#cite_note-3

    SELF EXPOSED!!!!!!!!!!!
    Facebook User ANG ZHAO HUI admit liao
    Mr Jackie, i have never left. i am just…..
    from sunshine days all the way to grand elitia…….
    Like wat Mr James said, are…..

  352. Jack Loo says:

    Jackie Hoo’s forex is not really forex .A lot of things they hidden.
    The ROI for 1 year is not really 125% or 150%. Is only 25% or 50% because when u put in USD500(Base),the investment start at 0. Somoe more you can not withdraw your money for 1 year.

  353. Jean says:

    All projects like SE/Emmax , AT the beginning they just paid money for fews month , When many members joint in – after 6 months maybe , then they will shut down the company and create another new company to con people. this is Fu-ker James Phang tactics,If you said SE/Emmax is a failed projects. Then somebody Please explain Fu-cker James Phang GE projects ….

  354. Jack Loo says:

    Jackie Hoo’s forex actually the ROI is only 25%(after 1 year) . Not 125% or 150% . Their investement is start to gain from 0 if you invest yr USD500 .and somemore you can not withdraw your investment money for 1 year .
    Other forex’s gaining is start frm USD500 and able to withdrawn the money any time.
    You can ask them more detail. Actually Jackie Hoo’s forex is bull shitng invester .I don’t know where they use their money to ?

  355. Jack Loo says:

    If you study properly .Actually is not high profit at all .They bull shit the invester .
    1) Normal Forex : Capital USD500 and then you gain 10% after 1 month .Your total is USD500+10%(USD50).This investment start at USD500.And some more you can take out yr own money anytime you wanted .
    2) For http://www.fxautobots.com.If you put in USD500 and win 10% for the following month . You total is only 10%(USD50)
    The investment is start at 0 . You can only withdraw your own money after 1 year .I don’t know what they do with your money.
    Which mean your actual ROI is only 25% after 1 year .not 125% .

    You better ask them properly .Don’t let them mis-lead you .

  356. Wongkc says:

    Yesterday a friend of mine approached by ex-sunshine leader from Singapore under Jackie Ho group. They are running a forex platform http://www.fxautobots.com .

    According to my friend, this platform is giving guaranteed profit of 0-15% a month, mean no loss, marketers will get 10-20% commission from collected fund. They have a strong statements show in pdf file but no live statement. When my friend show me their performance chart, it grow from 0 capital to extremely high profit.

    Can anyone clarify this? Any comment? pls

  357. Danial says:

    Ken Lee (Represantative of Sunshine Empire ) is trying promote their new forex company in KL .

    You may call him about your SE’s refund money . He may explain to you in detail what is going on .
    H/P: 016-4611518
    H/P: 65-90686892

  358. Saw says:

    ESA Trader is James Phang’s compnay . Trying to con people money . Evil company . Must tell everyone .

  359. Saw says:

    3 of my friends join ESA Trader . I have asked them to withdraw their money immediately . We all tired about James Phang’s scam already.

    • Dear Saw,

      I sincerely hope that you are not giving out advice without proper investigation. As I kept on mentioning, we have no direct and indirect dealings with James Phang. It is really very disappointing for someone to falsely advise people.

  360. James Phang hiding like a rat says:

    mother fu-cker james phang you are bitch …

  361. James Phang hiding like a rat says:

    mother fu-cker james phang must return money to all SE/Emmax/GE membes , All this members invested their projects and lost 100 % , Not return even 1 cents.

  362. Sg Member says:

    Illegal Compnay from singapore.
    Beware below scam companies by James Phang :
    1) ESA Trader (Forex)
    2) NZ Financial (Forex)
    3) Grand Royale International(GRI)
    4) Elite Trader (Forex)

  363. Frank says:

    Damn James Phang . Animal family .

  364. fuc-ker James Phang says:

    I want to curse fuc-ker james phang until his relative and families suffer finiancial problem also. Bad luck to fuc-ker James Phang.

  365. fuc-ker James Phang says:

    YES , At first i m very believed this fuc-ker james phang , But his promised like a shit , Just big talked only . And i invested until bankrupcy ( 20 GP + Macau Casino) due to i believe this projects from fuc-ker james phang .i introduce many friends and families to jointed in , But until now , We all got problem , If still cannot return the money , i will plan to suicide .
    Many friend hated me after they jointed Emmax/SE due to me , i gave him bad dream /life because of SE/Emmax.

    • look for solution says:

      U no need to die, not worth dying because of JP. At first i also feel like dying but if i die, i will never live to see JP suffer. I want to live long to see JP suffer 10 times what i’ve suffered. Doing business with JP will only have one winning party, no win-win situation. JP will spend his rest of his life cheating people but he will burn in hell. We should report to CAD & Bank Negara, this is the least we should do. Chinese Proverbs says never too late to take revenge even though it will take 10 years. Person should die is JP!

  366. junyang02 says:

    you are a big fool, why join at the first place? =)

  367. fuc-ker James Phang says:

    Fuc-ker JAMES PHANG YOU HAVE LET ALL THE MEMBERS DOWN.
    YOU HAVE MAKE MANY PEOPLE GOING TO BANKRUPT WHICH IS BECAUSE OF YOU.
    IM A BIG FOOL TRUSTING YOU.

  368. fuck-er James Phang says:

    Fuck-er JAMES PHANG YOU HAVE LET ALL THE MEMBERS DOWN.
    YOU HAVE MAKE MANY PEOPLE GOING TO BANKRUPT WHICH IS BECAUSE OF YOU.
    IM A BIG FOOL TRUSTING YOU.

  369. James Phang f-u-c-k his brother banana says:

    He is not stupid . His new name is :F-u-c-k-e-r James Phang . Every body can curse him until he pay back money for member.

  370. Victor Toh says:

    NOP to Sunshine Empire to Emmax to Grand Royale International(GRI).
    This stupid James Phang just know to change company name every year.
    I was wondering what is the new company name for next year ?
    James Phang’s member got the suffering only.

  371. James Phang f-u-c-k his brother banana says:

    F-u-c-k-i-n-g James Phang family will suffer all the bad thing since he still scam money , not now …maybe next time .

  372. Victor Toh says:

    Steve Tan himself already admitted that James Phang is the man behind Grand Royale International(GRI).All the current GRI’s projects is transfer from Sunshine Empire .

  373. James Phang f-u-c-k his brother banana says:

    Beware below scam companies by mother f-u-c-k-e-r James Phang :
    1) ESA Trader (Forex)
    2) NZ Financial (Forex)
    3) Grand Royale International
    4) Elite Trader (Forex)

  374. James Phang f-u-c-k his brother banana says:

    Beware below scam companies by Fucker James Phang:
    1) ESA Trader (Forex)
    2) NZ Financial (Forex)
    3) Grand Royale International
    4) Elite Trader (Forex)

  375. SE Singapore says:

    Anti-steeve .

    You should ask Steve Tan to show you the company regis cert . Maybe you do not dare to ask Steve Tan . I bet .James Phang is truly the man behind GRI .The the GRI project is converted frm SE.

  376. SE Singapore says:

    GRI (Grand Royale International) is really own by James Phang .You may ask GRI to show you the company registration cert . James Phang is the secret owner .He still don’t give up to scam ,cheat people . That is his nature . He is evil .

  377. James Phang f-u-c-k his brother banana says:

    Many members after jointed SE/Emmax lost their money and finiance Problem ( some borrow money from bank), Some even siuside ( i can said that) , We just “Warn ” all the people dont step down this trap by f-u-c-k-e-r James Phang .
    Beware below scam companies:
    1) ESA Trader (Forex)
    2) NZ Financial (Forex)
    3) Grand Royale International
    4) Elite Trader (Forex)

  378. junyang02 says:

    i am just a neutral party here.. whatever i can comment is that not ALL are in the same boat. You can comment on this way however i guess you must be super anti all MLM’s.. MLM is nothing wrong, it’s depend on the people are doing the right thing,system,right team they following to. Singapore have so many MLM’s company.. I guess we will never stop ending talking about SE or even further any company names that being mentioned here.
    SE is a history of facts, whether JP will be jailed, facts are always right as singapore is a lawful country. For those i can see who are defencing against each others, no point.. what’s for? waste your time spending your negative thoughts over here.. Do something to achieve your stuffs. Even you are winning, who bothers? Of cause i feel bad for SE members, and nothing can be controlled. If you are SE , how you going to refund the members IF accounts is being all freezed by government?? The case will definately still going on even no evidence against SE.
    Save your time bothering over here. =)

  379. James Phang f-u-c-k his brother banana says:

    anti-steeve:
    The true is :
    James Phang not return money for member since nov2007 . Just Big talk and scam money …this is proof

  380. anti-steeve says:

    please show the proof.
    i did not see anybody to go to the gri office and demand for $$$.
    i did not see james phang in the office.
    i did not see the 5 people order by james phang to chase you and another 2 se member out of the office.
    show me the proof lor.
    so that you can convince me to join in to your line as anti social.
    for james phang.

    if you cant proof, please shut up your mouth o.k
    you can’t lay infront of the gri member. who know the real story

  381. James Phang f-u-c-k his brother banana says:

    IF SHIT MAN james phang nothing can do , he should stop GRI business , He is still thinking scam more money , he should stay jail for whole life like taiwan ex-president. Everybody can curse and f-u-c-k him .

  382. James Phang f-u-c-k his brother banana says:

    We cannot forget our hard earn money , he must go to jail , or whem old member see you , all can kick his butt and face. He must pay our lost . GRI is another scam company , Please ask your family dont joint .

  383. Tony SG says:

    We also met James Phang promoting GRI . He also suggested to old SE member try to forget the money .There is no way he can pay back our money. There is nothing he can do .

  384. James Phang f-u-c-k his brother banana says:

    Stevee:
    That why we should go together , the more people we go , the more profit we can negotiate . only few peoples go ….. cannot. We every day protect at his office. Let him eat banana.

  385. Stevee says:

    Last night, i and my 2 SE member go to Singapore office to ask about our re-fund .James Phang ordered 5 people to chase us out of the office .What should we do ?

    • anti steeve says:

      hi
      don’t anyhow bull shit o.k stevee. on 10 & 11 september itself i’m at the grand royale international office.
      i did not see anyone of you guys which you have mentioned going in to the gri office.
      james phang is not the ceo of the GRI. the deo is dr steve tan.
      james phang is not come to the gri office how come he can ask 5 people to chase you and another 2 se member out of the office.
      if you want to talk big please go and find out more details then bull shit o.k.
      do you think that every people like you no brain to think. especially infront of the gri member.
      proof to me lor it is real one and i will fellow your step to be ant-james phang also.
      check the roc of gri and see who the ceo is.
      that just anyhow bull shit o.k

  386. Wood says:

    Grand Royale International :James Phang’s new office.
    Malaysia Office: 6-2, Jln PJS 8/12A, Dataran Mentari, Petaling Jaya 46150.
    Singapore Office: 1 Coleman Street #06-07 The Adelphi Singapore 179803

  387. James Phang f-u-c-k his brother banana says:

    Victor :
    Please let every body know next week when ? go to GRI office to meet f-u-c-k-e-r james phang , We need to team work . Not only you , Let singapore news paper expose this thing. Our way is easy … He must return all our hard earn money + interest .

  388. Jeez says:

    Grand Elitia is Desmond’s idea, not JP’s. Emmax was a trying-to-be-legitimate company which collasped when it tried to take on Sunshine Empire’s burden. No wonder both didn’t work out.

  389. victor says:

    Next week i will gather all my old SE’s downline to go to GRI office the ask for our re-fund money from James Phang .James Phang must return our money .

  390. Victim says:

    Grand Royale International(GRI) is truely James Phang’s company . He prometed GRI at Sg office last 2 week .
    That night , James Phang refused to answer the question about Sunshine Empir members money .Same old style .Talk big . Talk cock . And all empty promises .

  391. Felix Ker says:

    What’s the address to CAD website?

  392. Victim says:

    Joyceline ,
    GRI “Grand Royale Internatioanl” marketing plan is only selling Business Centre . No much about their product .Ask yourself Joyceline : How much is yr sales from selling Business Centre ? How much sales you sell from yr product ? GRI markeitng plan is illegal scam . Will be close down within 15 month or sooner.

    • joyce says:

      give me your e-mail address.
      in 15 month time if it is not close not.
      i will make sure you yourself come in to gri without making any more stupid complain.
      use your brain to think.
      if singapore govt have the proof james phang should go to jail already.

  393. Victim says:

    Joyceline ,
    SE might freeze by sg gov . How about Emmax,Grand Elitia ? James Phang did the same thing: No Payout to members .What is the excuses ? No more excuses . James Phang causing to many ppl loss money & suffer .

  394. hehe says:

    Hi Patrick,

    well, Do you really know the fact on CAD cases?if the company already plan to move to next company to continue scam, do u think will left somethings for CAD?the fact is highest management report themself to CAD to freeze their company?of course, before this, already move a large of money to another company b4 freeze.the answer very easy,if network continue grow, they will over paidout to the merchant who get 3 times returns, sure b4 this happen they plan to move to the new company.As you said that singapore biz model is too old,how singapore’s market still steady?of course new biz model like MLM is good model,even MLM biz also need you to work it only earn…for SE,jz put in the money and will get back return 2 to 3 times with no risk plus refer ppl also got commission,money come from where?”羊毛长在羊身上”do u know that USA currently facing very serious finacial problem?do you know that USA also got SCAM company?even SHARE MARKET also got risk.Yup,u can said bank is scam but they got legal license,u cannot do anythings and bank will got 2 to 3 times for interest,if u said bank is scam then u dun put ur money to bank,better keep it at ur home, even goverment scam your money then u got power against them?

  395. hehe says:

    Hi Joyceline,

    The actual fact is you still cannot face the reality.Do you proof that GRAND ROYALE INTERNATIONAL not under JP?if u also no proof then u cannot comment other ppl also.Ppl comment here sure got their reason.”无风不起浪”.ppl got freedom post their comment here, u cannot blame and scold them mouse hiding, this is the place let ppl comment.if you feel not well here, u can left here.if ppl got plan to scam ppl’s money, u think that ppl so stupid left anythings which is risky themself for goverments?

  396. neutral says:

    use your brain to think
    no proof
    the govt dare not to anyhow charge them to court.
    if have it will like the monk and the nkf president already.
    think it before you all make any comment o.k

  397. neutral says:

    almak why ecerybody don’t find out the actual fact.
    always keep on blaming.
    GRAND ROYALE INTERNATIONAL – do you have any proof that it is under james phang.
    if you can’t proof it can you please don’t anyhow put any comment on it.
    very unfair where you don’t know hear or tail.
    please also don’t ask me to post here.
    e-mail to my [email protected] if you dare to.
    don’t like a mouse hiding only know how to make bad comment at these platform only.

Leave a Reply