I’m just another professional-wannabe photographer trying to learn more. After finish reading this entry, you will realise how much I hate filters right now.
Here’s what exactly happened. For almost a year, I’ve been using my Nikon AF-D 35mm f/2.0 for uncountable shoots. And after every shoot, I’ll start wondering why this piece of lens, reviewed as one of the great primes out there, produces photos with really lousy contrast. I used a Hoya UV Guard filter. Anyway, I got really sick of the 35mm and nearly sold it (here). On the day of posting, I decided to remove the filter to clean the lens up and realised that shots taken with the filter degraded my photo quality by a lot.
The test was done with:
Nikon D90 (All photos were shot on RAW with NO POST PROCESSING)
Nikon Nikkor AF-D 35mm f/2.0
Read the whole test after the jump!
Above: Whole photo of the test scene used. The photo was saved with PhotoShop at Quality 8/12.
All test shots were shot at f/4.5, 0.8secs at ISO 200.
Above: 100% without any Filter.
Above: 100% Crop with Hoya UV GUARD (JAPAN).
If you look closely, details were kept rather well, The filter caused the photo to lose too much contrast. This was the biggest problem when I used the lens.
Above: 100% Crop with Kenko (Digital Filter) UV.
On a Kenko, the photo actually turns out rather blur. It’s not handshake as the camera was left on a table opposite. Lots of details were lost, retaining some contrast.
Above: 100% Crop with SteinZeiser Germany MC UV.
This is the worst filter for the test. Say good bye to your details and a little contrast. Never get this filter if you want some decent photographs.
Top: Used Hoya UV Guard
Bottom: No filter
Both: Nikon D90 (RAW), Nikon Nikkor AF-D 50mm f/1.4, shot at f/2.0, 1/15, ISO 200. No post processing done.
This may be a brief review but with the 4 shots, tested using 3 different filters, I realised that filters in a way or another degrade the photograph I take.
If you must have a filter and you really need a budget one, get Kenko. Kenko doesn’t kill too much details and gives you fair contrast.
If you can, do without a filter. Your photos should appear best without any filter.
I am not paid to do this test.
This test was done on filters that cost less as I have no budget for anything like B+W. If you would like to send me donations to get more filters and continue the test, feel free to send me the donation via paypal – [email protected].
* All photos above have original EXIF intact.